The debate over light in darkness and the Catholicity of Hans Urs Von Balthasar

Journal article

Ormerod, Neil. (2013). The debate over light in darkness and the Catholicity of Hans Urs Von Balthasar. Australian Ejournal of Theology. 20(3), pp. 207 - 220.
AuthorsOrmerod, Neil
Abstract

The publication of Alyssa Pitstick's Light in Darkness has raised questions about the status of von Balthasar's theology, in particular his theology of the descent of Jesus. The paper will consider her claims, and responses to her thesis, and those of others who have raised critical questions about his theology. It will not address the question as to the orthodoxy of his theology, but will ask how his theology can contain so many elements which stretch boundaries yet not attract official concern. It will consider his position on the descent into Hell, divine immutability, his Trinitarian thought and his position on the beatific vision of Jesus. It will compare his treatment with that given to the writing of Sobrino's Christology.

Year2013
JournalAustralian Ejournal of Theology
Journal citation20 (3), pp. 207 - 220
PublisherSchool of Theology, Australian Catholic University
ISSN1448-6326
Web address (URL)https://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=a9h&AN=94925082&site=ehost-live&scope=site
Page range207 - 220
Research GroupSchool of Theology
Publisher's version
File Access Level
Controlled
Place of publicationAustralia
Permalink -

https://acuresearchbank.acu.edu.au/item/851y0/the-debate-over-light-in-darkness-and-the-catholicity-of-hans-urs-von-balthasar

Log in to edit

Restricted files

Publisher's version

  • 137
    total views
  • 0
    total downloads
  • 2
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month
These values are for the period from 19th October 2020, when this repository was created.

Export as

Related outputs

Gilson and Lonergan : A test case on science and metaphysics
Ormerod, Neil. (2022). Gilson and Lonergan : A test case on science and metaphysics. The Heythrop Journal. 63(4), pp. 796-806. https://doi.org/10.1111/heyj.12160
The quest for the historical Jesus as an experiment in theological method : A Lonerganian perspective
Ormerod, Neil. (2020). The quest for the historical Jesus as an experiment in theological method : A Lonerganian perspective. Irish Theological Quarterly. 85(4), pp. 389-404. https://doi.org/10.1177/0021140020948378
Social science and ideological critiques of ecclesiology
Ormerod, Neil. (2018). Social science and ideological critiques of ecclesiology. In In Avis, Paul (Ed.). The Oxford handbook of ecclesiology pp. 553-572 Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordhb/9780199645831.013.16
Sacred heart, beatific mind : Exploring the consciousness of Jesus
Ormerod, Neil and Jacobs-Vandegeer, Christiaan. (2018). Sacred heart, beatific mind : Exploring the consciousness of Jesus. Theological Studies. 79(4), pp. 729-744. https://doi.org/10.1177/0040563918801184
John Henry Newman and trajectories for the development of doctrine
Ormerod, Neil. (2018). John Henry Newman and trajectories for the development of doctrine. Louvain Studies. 41(1), pp. 3-18. https://doi.org/10.2143/LS.41.1.3284691
Doing the will of the father : Jesus’ freedom and the beatific vision
Ormerod, Neil. (2018). Doing the will of the father : Jesus’ freedom and the beatific vision. Irish Theological Quarterly. 83(3), pp. 203-216. https://doi.org/10.1177/0021140018768336
A trajectory from Augustine to Aquinas and Lonergan: Contingent predication and the Trinity
Ormerod, Neil. (2017). A trajectory from Augustine to Aquinas and Lonergan: Contingent predication and the Trinity. Irish Theological Quarterly. 82(3), pp. 208 - 221. https://doi.org/10.1177/0021140017709423
Gilson and Lonergan and the possibility of a Christian philosophy
Ormerod, Neil. (2016). Gilson and Lonergan and the possibility of a Christian philosophy. The Heythrop Journal. 57(3), pp. 532 - 541. https://doi.org/10.1111/heyj.12235
The place of the Papacy in a historically concious ecclesiology
Ormerod, Neil James. (2016). The place of the Papacy in a historically concious ecclesiology. In In J. Chryssavgis (Ed.). Primacy in the Church: The Office of Primate and the Authority of Councils pp. 767 - 783 St Vladimir's Seminary Press.
Sensus Fidei and sociology: How do we find the normative in the empirical?
Ormerod, Neil James. (2016). Sensus Fidei and sociology: How do we find the normative in the empirical? In In B. Hinze and P. Phan (Ed.). Learning from All the Faithful: A Contemporary Theology of the Sensus Fidei pp. 89 - 102 Wipf & Stock Publishers.
"for in him the whole fullness of Deity dwells bodily": The Trinitarian Depths of the Incarnation
Ormerod, Neil. (2016). "for in him the whole fullness of Deity dwells bodily": The Trinitarian Depths of the Incarnation. Theological Studies. 77(4), pp. 803 - 822. https://doi.org/10.1177/0040563916666822
Ecological conversion: What does it mean?
Ormerod, Neil and Vanin, Cristina. (2016). Ecological conversion: What does it mean? Theological Studies. 77(2), pp. 328 - 352. https://doi.org/10.1177/0040563916640694
Global pentecostal consultations - Receptive ecumenism in practice or, 'any friend of Jesus is a friend of mine'
Ormerod, Neil. (2015). Global pentecostal consultations - Receptive ecumenism in practice or, 'any friend of Jesus is a friend of mine'. Pacifica: Australasian theological studies. 28(2), pp. 149 - 159. https://doi.org/10.1177/1030570X16648723
Bernard Lonergan's Contribution to Inter-Religious Dialogue
Ormerod, Neil. (2015). Bernard Lonergan's Contribution to Inter-Religious Dialogue. In G. Whelan (Ed.). Revisiting Lonergan's Anthropology. Italy: Gregorian and Biblical Press. pp. 205 - 220
Foundational theology: A new approach to Catholic fundamental theology
Ormerod, Neil and Jacobs-Vandegeer, Christiaan. (2015). Foundational theology: A new approach to Catholic fundamental theology Fortress Press.
A public God: Natural theology reconsidered
Ormerod, Neil. (2015). A public God: Natural theology reconsidered Fortress Press.
A (non- communio) Trinitarian ecclesiology: Grounded in grace, lived in faith, hope, and charity
Ormerod, Neil. (2015). A (non- communio) Trinitarian ecclesiology: Grounded in grace, lived in faith, hope, and charity. Theological Studies: a jesuit-sponsored journal of theology. 76(3), pp. 448 - 467. https://doi.org/10.1177/0040563915593470
On the maturation of Receptive Ecumenism: The connection between Receptive Ecumenism and Spiritual Ecumenism
Pizzey, Antonia, Lenehan, Kevin and Ormerod, Neil. (2015). On the maturation of Receptive Ecumenism: The connection between Receptive Ecumenism and Spiritual Ecumenism. Pacifica: Australasian theological studies. 28(2), pp. 108 - 125. https://doi.org/10.1177/1030570X16649408
Operative and cooperative grace and the question of justification by faith: A contemporary transposition
Ormerod, Neil. (2015). Operative and cooperative grace and the question of justification by faith: A contemporary transposition. Irish Theological Quarterly. 80(3), pp. 248 - 258. https://doi.org/10.1177/0021140015583251
Re-visioning the Church: An experiment in systematic-historical ecclesiology
Ormerod, Neil. (2014). Re-visioning the Church: An experiment in systematic-historical ecclesiology Fortress Press.
Doran's The Trinity in History: The Girardian Connection
Ormerod, Neil. (2014). Doran's The Trinity in History: The Girardian Connection. Method: Journal of Lonergan Studies. 4(1), pp. 47 - 59.
Addendum to the grace-nature distinction
Ormerod, Neil. (2014). Addendum to the grace-nature distinction. Theological Studies. 75(4), pp. 890 - 898. https://doi.org/10.1177/0040563914551494
The metaphysics of holiness: Created participation in the divine nature
Ormerod, Neil. (2014). The metaphysics of holiness: Created participation in the divine nature. Irish Theological Quarterly. 79(1), pp. 68 - 82. https://doi.org/10.1177/0021140013509438
The grace-nature distinction and the construction of a systematic theology
Ormerod, Neil. (2014). The grace-nature distinction and the construction of a systematic theology. Theological Studies. 75(3), pp. 515 - 536. https://doi.org/10.1177/0040563914538718
Bernard Lonergan and the recovery of a metaphysical frame
Ormerod, Neil. (2013). Bernard Lonergan and the recovery of a metaphysical frame. Theological Studies. 74(4), pp. 960 - 982.
Creator God, evolving world
Ormerod, Neil and Crysdale, Cynthia. (2013). Creator God, evolving world Fortress Press.
Christ, globalization and the Church
Ormerod, Neil. (2013). Christ, globalization and the Church. Journal of Moral Theology. 2(1), pp. 98 - 112.
Soul of a poet, mind of a theologian: exploring science and religion
Ormerod, Neil. (2013). Soul of a poet, mind of a theologian: exploring science and religion. In In N Ormerod and R Gascoigne (Ed.). Priest, poet and theologian: essays in honour of Anthony Kelly CSsR pp. 60 - 76 Mosaic Press.
Mission driven and identity shaped: Ex Corde Ecclesiae revisited
Ormerod, Neil. (2013). Mission driven and identity shaped: Ex Corde Ecclesiae revisited. Irish Theological Quarterly. 78(4), pp. 325 - 337. https://doi.org/10.1177/0021140013497441
Desire and cultural origins: Lonergan and Girard in conversation
Ormerod, Neil. (2013). Desire and cultural origins: Lonergan and Girard in conversation. The Heythrop Journal. 54(5), pp. 784 - 795. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-2265.2011.00697.x
Theology and the new atheism: Science, religion and metaphysics
Ormerod, Neil. (2013). Theology and the new atheism: Science, religion and metaphysics. Theology. 116(3), pp. 187 - 194. https://doi.org/10.1177/0040571X12472598
For what are we responsible? Gaudium et Spes 34 and the human project
Ormerod, Neil. (2013). For what are we responsible? Gaudium et Spes 34 and the human project. In In DG Kirchhoffer, R Horner and P McCardle (Ed.). Being human: groundwork for a theological anthropology for the 21st century pp. 191 - 202 Mosaic Press.
Does Scientific Inquiry Preclude Belief in God? : Science and religion in Australian Media
Ormerod, Neil. (2012). Does Scientific Inquiry Preclude Belief in God? : Science and religion in Australian Media. Uniting Church Studies. 18(2), pp. 75 - 82.
The laity in the Australian Church
Ormerod, Neil. (2012). The laity in the Australian Church. In In N Ormerod, O Rush and D Pascoe (Ed.). Vatican II: Reception and implementation in the Australian Church pp. 62 - 75 Garratt Publishing.
Vatican II : Reception and implementation in the Australian church
Ormerod, Neil, Rush, Ormond, Pascoe, David James, Johnson, Clare and Hodge, Joel. (2012). Vatican II : Reception and implementation in the Australian church Garrett Publishing.
Questioning desire: Lonergan, Girard and Buddhism
Ormerod, Neil. (2012). Questioning desire: Lonergan, Girard and Buddhism. Louvain Studies. 36(4), pp. 356 - 371. https://doi.org/10.2143/LS.36.4.3019241
Ecclesiology and exclusion : setting boundaries for the Church
Ormerod, Neil. (2012). Ecclesiology and exclusion : setting boundaries for the Church. In In D M Doyle, T J Furry and P D Bazzell (Ed.). Ecclesiology and Exclusion: Boundaries of Being and Belonging in Postmodern Times pp. 215 - 220 Orbis Books.
The development of Catholic social teaching on economics : Bernard Lonergan and Benedict XVI
Ormerod, Neil, Oslington, Paul and Koning, Robin. (2012). The development of Catholic social teaching on economics : Bernard Lonergan and Benedict XVI. Theological Studies. 73(2), pp. 391 - 421.
Clergy sexual abuse : what difference did Vatican II make?
Ormerod, Neil. (2012). Clergy sexual abuse : what difference did Vatican II make? In In N Ormerod, O Rush and D Pascoe (Ed.). Vatican II: Reception and implementation in the Australian Church pp. 213 - 225 Garratt Publishing.
The four point hypothesis : transpositions and complications
Ormerod, Neil. (2012). The four point hypothesis : transpositions and complications. Irish Theological Quarterly. 77(2), pp. 127 - 140.
Intellectual Conversion in Book 7 of the Confessions
Ormerod, Neil. (2012). Intellectual Conversion in Book 7 of the Confessions. Pacifica: Australasian theological studies. 25(1), pp. 12 - 22.
Is all desire mimetic? : Lonergan and Girard on the nature of desire and authenticity
Ormerod, Neil. (2012). Is all desire mimetic? : Lonergan and Girard on the nature of desire and authenticity. In In S Cowdell, C Fleming and J Hodge (Ed.). Violence, desire, and the sacred: Girard's mimetic theory across the disciplines pp. 251 - 262 Continuum International Publishing Group Ltd.
Virtues in a globalized context
Ormerod, Neil. (2011). Virtues in a globalized context. In In L. Anceschi, J. A. Camilleri and R. Palapathwala & A. Wicking (Ed.). Religion and ethics in a globalizing world: Conflict, dialogue, and transformation pp. 67 - 83 Palgrave Macmillan.
Transposing theology into the categories of meaning
Ormerod, Neil. (2011). Transposing theology into the categories of meaning. Gregorianum. 92(3), pp. 517 - 532.
Contingent Predication and the Four-Point Hypothesis
Ormerod, Neil. (2011). Contingent Predication and the Four-Point Hypothesis. In In N Ormerod, O Rush and D Pascoe (Ed.). Fifty years of Insight: Bernard Lonergan's contribution to philosophy and theology pp. 109 - 118 Australasian Theological Forum Ltd.
Heresy or orthodoxy: A question of theological style
Ormerod, Neil. (2011). Heresy or orthodoxy: A question of theological style. St. Mark's Review. 215(1), pp. 63 - 70.
Globalisation and Catholic Social Teaching
Ormerod, Neil. (2011). Globalisation and Catholic Social Teaching. In In N Ormerod and P Oslington (Ed.). Globalisation and the Church: Reflections on Caritas in Veritate pp. 149 - 158 St Pauls Publications.
Preliminary steps towards a natural theology
Ormerod, Neil. (2011). Preliminary steps towards a natural theology. Irish Theological Quarterly. 76(2), pp. 115 - 127.
The knowledge and authority of Jesus: A response to Bishop Robinson
Ormerod, Neil. (2011). The knowledge and authority of Jesus: A response to Bishop Robinson. Australasian Catholic Record. 88(1), pp. 88 - 97.
Creator God, evolving world
Ormerod, Neil. (2010). Creator God, evolving world. St Mark's Review: a journal of Christian thought and opinion. 211(1), pp. 76 - 82.
A Trinitarian Primer
Ormerod, Neil. (2010). A Trinitarian Primer St Pauls Publications.
Identity and mission in Catholic agencies
Ormerod, Neil. (2010). Identity and mission in Catholic agencies. Australasian Catholic Record. 87(4), pp. 430 - 439.
Secularisation and the "rise" of atheism
Ormerod, Neil. (2010). Secularisation and the "rise" of atheism. Australian Ejournal of Theology. 17, pp. 13 - 22.
Vatican II - continuity or discontinuity? Towards an ontology of meaning
Ormerod, Neil. (2010). Vatican II - continuity or discontinuity? Towards an ontology of meaning. Theological Studies. 71(3), pp. 609 - 636. https://doi.org/10.1177/004056391007100305
Conversation on Paul Oslington's Deus Economicus
Kelly, Anthony and Ormerod, Neil. (2009). Conversation on Paul Oslington's Deus Economicus. Australian Ejournal of Theology.
What is the goal of systematic theology?
Ormerod, Neil. (2009). What is the goal of systematic theology? Irish Theological Quarterly. 74(1), pp. 38 - 52. https://doi.org/10.1177/0021140008098843
Charles Taylor and Bernard Lonergan on natural theology
Ormerod, Neil. (2009). Charles Taylor and Bernard Lonergan on natural theology. Irish Theological Quarterly. 74(4), pp. 419 - 433. https://doi.org/10.1177/0021140009343368
Catholics and Pentecostals - a shared mission in a globalising world
Ormerod, Neil. (2009). Catholics and Pentecostals - a shared mission in a globalising world. Australasian Pentecostal Studies.
Globalization and the mission of the Church
Ormerod, Neil J. and Clifton, Shane. (2009). Globalization and the mission of the Church T&T Clark International.
History and theology in dialogue on the Trinity
Ormerod, Neil. (2008). History and theology in dialogue on the Trinity. Pacifica: Journal of the Melbourne College of Divinity. 21(2), pp. 146 - 159.
The argument has vast implications: Part II of deus caritas est
Ormerod, Neil James. (2008). The argument has vast implications: Part II of deus caritas est. In In N. Ormerod (Ed.). Identity and Mission in Catholic Agencies pp. 67 - 81 St Pauls Publications.
Recent ecclesiology: A survey
Ormerod, Neil. (2008). Recent ecclesiology: A survey. Pacifica: Australasian theological studies. 21(1), pp. 57 - 67.
Ecclesiology and the social sciences
Ormerod, Neil James. (2008). Ecclesiology and the social sciences. In In G Mannion and L. Mudge (Ed.). The Routledge Companion to the Christian Church pp. 639 - 654 Routledge.
Catholic schools: Ministry or mission?
Ormerod, Neil. (2008). Catholic schools: Ministry or mission? Australasian Catholic Record. 85(2), pp. 212 - 219.
John Paul II and interfaith dialogue
Ormerod, Neil James. (2007). John Paul II and interfaith dialogue. In In R. Gascoigne (Ed.). John Paul II: legacy and witness pp. 113 - 118 St Pauls Publications.
God and politics
Ormerod, Neil. (2007). God and politics. Australasian Catholic Record. 84(1), pp. 3 - 10.
Creation, grace, and redemption
Ormerod, Neil James. (2007). Creation, grace, and redemption Orbis Books.
Two points or four? - Rahner and Lonergan on trinity, incarnation, grace, and beatific vision
Ormerod, Neil. (2007). Two points or four? - Rahner and Lonergan on trinity, incarnation, grace, and beatific vision. Theological Studies. 68(3), pp. 661 - 673. https://doi.org/10.1177/004056390706800309
In defence of natural theology: Bringing God into the public realm
Ormerod, Neil. (2007). In defence of natural theology: Bringing God into the public realm. Irish Theological Quarterly. 72(3), pp. 227 - 241. https://doi.org/10.1177/0021140007085486
On the divine institution of the three-fold ministry
Ormerod, Neil. (2007). On the divine institution of the three-fold ministry. Ecclesiology: the journal for ministry, mission and unity. 4(1), pp. 38 - 51. https://doi.org/10.1177/1744136607080895
Resurrection and cosmic eschatology
Ormerod, Neil James. (2007). Resurrection and cosmic eschatology. In In J. Haire, C. Ledger and S. Pickard (Ed.). From Resurrection to Return: Perspectives from Theology and Science on Christian Eschatology pp. 157 - 171 Australian Theological Forum Press.
Theology, history and globalization
Ormerod, Neil. (2007). Theology, history and globalization. Gregorianum. 88(1), pp. 23 - 48.
"The times they are a 'changin'": A response to O'Malley and Schloesser
Ormerod, Neil. (2006). "The times they are a 'changin'": A response to O'Malley and Schloesser. Theological Studies. 67(4), pp. 834 - 855. https://doi.org/10.1177/004056390606700405
What is the task of systematic theology?
Ormerod, Neil. (2006). What is the task of systematic theology? Australian Ejournal of Theology.
A dialectic engagement with the social sciences in an ecclesiological context
Ormerod, Neil. (2005). A dialectic engagement with the social sciences in an ecclesiological context. Theological Studies. 66(4), pp. 815 - 840. https://doi.org/10.1177/004056390506600404
Faith and reason: Perspectives from Macintyre and Lonergan
Ormerod, Neil. (2005). Faith and reason: Perspectives from Macintyre and Lonergan. Heythrop Journal: a Quarterly Review of Philosophy and Theology. 46(1), pp. 11 - 22. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-2265.2005.00247.x
Intelligent design or divine providence
Ormerod, Neil. (2005). Intelligent design or divine providence. Ethics Education: a journal for applied philosophy and ethics in the Christian tradition. 11(2), pp. 25 - 31.
Power and authority - a response to bishop Cullinane
Ormerod, Neil. (2005). Power and authority - a response to bishop Cullinane. Australasian Catholic Record. 82(2), pp. 154 - 162.
The Trinity: Retrieving the western tradition
Ormerod, Neil James. (2005). The Trinity: Retrieving the western tradition Marquette University Press.
Chance and necessity; providence and God
Ormerod, Neil. (2005). Chance and necessity; providence and God. Irish Theological Quarterly. 70, pp. 263 - 278.
The dual language of sacrifice
Ormerod, Neil. (2004). The dual language of sacrifice. Pacifica: Australasian theological studies. 17(2), pp. 159 - 169.
One God, many paths?
Ormerod, Neil James. (2004). One God, many paths? In In R. Lennan (Ed.). The Possibility of Belief: The Challenges and Prospects of Catholic Faith pp. 51 - 66 St Pauls Publications.
Can Christian marriage survive?
Ormerod, Neil James. (2004). Can Christian marriage survive? In In R. Lennan (Ed.). The Possibility of Belief: The Challenges and Prospects of Catholic Faith pp. 207 - 220 St Pauls Publications.
Reconciliation and the paschal mystery
Ormerod, Neil James. (2004). Reconciliation and the paschal mystery. In In G. Moore (Ed.). Reconciliation: A Hunger in Society and the Church pp. 41 - 53 St Pauls Publications.
Mission and ministry in the wake of Vatican II
Ormerod, Neil. (2003). Mission and ministry in the wake of Vatican II. Australian Ejournal of Theology.
Wrestling with Rahner on the trinity
Ormerod, Neil. (2003). Wrestling with Rahner on the trinity. Irish Theological Quarterly. 68(3), pp. 213 - 227.
The evangelising diocese: A response to Martin Teulan
Ormerod, Neil. (2003). The evangelising diocese: A response to Martin Teulan. Australasian Catholic Record. 80(1), pp. 62 - 69.
Augustine and the trinity: Whose crisis?
Ormerod, Neil. (2003). Augustine and the trinity: Whose crisis? Pacifica: Australasian theological studies. 16(1), pp. 17 - 32.
Augustine's de trin1tate and Lonergan's realms of meaning
Ormerod, Neil. (2003). Augustine's de trin1tate and Lonergan's realms of meaning. Theological Studies. 64(4), pp. 773 - 794. https://doi.org/10.1177/004056390306400405
The structure of a systematic ecclesiology
Ormerod, Neil. (2002). The structure of a systematic ecclesiology. Theological Studies. 63(1), pp. 3 - 30.