History and SOSE : Where to now?

Journal article


Hart, Catherine Robyn. (2008). History and SOSE : Where to now? Curriculum Perspectives. 28(1), pp. 75-81.
AuthorsHart, Catherine Robyn
Abstract

[Extract] THE PROBABLE (INEVITABLE?) MANDATING of Australian history across all Australian secondary (and possibly primary) schools offers school history a chance at what many see as revival. It is a chance for school history to regain status as a stand alone subject, as a monolithic disciplinary entity (Goodson, 1983), and a chance for the return of specialist disciplinary teachers; but is this a good thing? Given that this 'resurrection' will most likely come in the form of a national Australian history curriculum (which is in itself swathed in the rhetoric of standards and accountability), this is problematic. So too are claims of 'resurrection' as many schools, especially those in NSW, have continued to teach history as a separate subject. At the same time, SOSE is under threat. In a number of states and territories SOSE no longer formally exists (nor for that matter do KLAs), and SOSE has variously been labelled as 'mickey mouse', the 'social slops' and a 'mish-mash of incomprehensible sludge'. W hilst concerns about SOSE, the knowledge bases it is founded on, its curricular structure and teachers abilities to effectively teach across such a broad KLA are not unfounded (see for example Schultz, 2006); such derisive criticisms overlook both the potential for SOSE and indeed the effectiveness of SOSE in many schools as Tudball has highlighted.

In the first part of this paper I overview the current policy contexts driving the history and SOSE debate and detail the criticisms that have been levelled at both history and SOSE. In doing so I also examine which concerns are justified and which are more a result of misperceplion. I subsequently explore ways in which these concerns could be addressed in terms of curriculum development, teacher preparation and pedagogy. You will note that the ordering of the terms 'history' and 'SOSE' varies throughout this paper - this is quite deliberate as it reflects the changing focus in the history and SOSE debate. Throughout much of the 1990s and early twenty-first century discussion was centred on SOSE and history was positioned in many states as peripheral to SOSE, whilst the focal point of current policy contexts is history and, to a much lesser extent, SOSE.

Year2008
JournalCurriculum Perspectives
Journal citation28 (1), pp. 75-81
PublisherAustralian Curriculum Studies Association
ISSN0159-7868
Page range75-81
Research GroupSchool of Education
Publisher's version
License
All rights reserved
File Access Level
Controlled
Output statusPublished
Publication dates
Print2008
Permalink -

https://acuresearchbank.acu.edu.au/item/87zvq/history-and-sose-where-to-now

Restricted files

Publisher's version

  • 81
    total views
  • 0
    total downloads
  • 1
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month
These values are for the period from 19th October 2020, when this repository was created.

Export as

Related outputs

Global Empires: Ten Ideas to Get You Started Ten ideas to assist teachers plan and prepare for the new VCE Global Empires units.
Edwards, Greg, Bourke, Connor, Cape, Lauren, Wolff, James, O’Connor, Alexandra and Hart, Catherine. (2015). Global Empires: Ten Ideas to Get You Started Ten ideas to assist teachers plan and prepare for the new VCE Global Empires units. Agora. 50(4), pp. 65 - 68.
National Curriculum and Federalism: The Australian Experience.
Harris-Hart, Catherine. (2010). National Curriculum and Federalism: The Australian Experience. Journal of Educational Administration and History. 42(3), pp. 295 - 313. https://doi.org/10.1080/00220620.2010.492965
Performing curriculum : exploring the role of teachers and teacher educators
Harris-Hart, Catherine. (2009). Performing curriculum : exploring the role of teachers and teacher educators. Curriculum Inquiry. 39(1), pp. 111 - 123.
Teaching Australian history : a temporally inclusive approach
Hart, Catherine Robyn. (2008). Teaching Australian history : a temporally inclusive approach. The Social Educator. 26(1), pp. 26 - 32.
Exploring creative music making as a vehicle for integrated teaching and learning
Joseph, Dawn and Harris-Hart, Catherine. (2008). Exploring creative music making as a vehicle for integrated teaching and learning. The XXXth Annual Conference of the Australian and New Zealand Association for Research in Music Education 2008. Melbourne, Australia: Australian and New Zealand Association for Research in Music Education (ANZARME). pp. 147 - 159
Curriculum frameworks: who (or what) is framing whom?
Marsh, Colin and Harris, Catherine. (2007). Curriculum frameworks: who (or what) is framing whom? Curriculum and Teaching. 22(2), pp. 29 - 42. https://doi.org/10.7459/ct/22.2.03
The social construction of computing and information technology subject subculture
Hart, Catherine Robyn. (2007). The social construction of computing and information technology subject subculture. In Gender and IT: Ongoing Challenges for Computing and Information Technology Education in Australian Secondary Education pp. 81 - 95 Australian Curriculum Studies Association.
The promise of cultural institutions: learning SOSE beyond the classroom
Hart, Catherine Robyn. (2006). The promise of cultural institutions: learning SOSE beyond the classroom. The Social Educator. 24(1), pp. 44 - 49.
Analysing curriculum change : some reconceptualised approaches,
Harris, Catherine and Marsh, Colin. (2005). Analysing curriculum change : some reconceptualised approaches,. In Curriculum Development in Australia: Promising Initiatives, Impasses and Dead Ends pp. 15 - 38 Open Book Publishers.
The key learning area movement : a force for pedagogical change or a facade for continued conservatism?
Harris, Catherine. (2005). The key learning area movement : a force for pedagogical change or a facade for continued conservatism? In Curriculum Development in Australia: Promising Initiatives, Impasses and Dead Ends pp. 53 - 62 Open Book Publishers.
Curriculum theorising: examining the middle ground of curriculum
Harris, Catherine. (2005). Curriculum theorising: examining the middle ground of curriculum. Curriculum and Teaching. 20(2), pp. 81 - 96. https://doi.org/10.7459/ct/20.2.06