Guthrie Wilson and the trans-Tasman educational career

Journal article


Prentis, Malcolm. (2013) Guthrie Wilson and the trans-Tasman educational career. History of Education Review. 42(1), pp. 69 - 84. https://doi.org/10.1108/08198691311317705
AuthorsPrentis, Malcolm
Abstract

Purpose: Guthrie Wilson (1914‐1984) was one example of the trend of migration of teachers from New Zealand public schools to Australian private schools. The purpose of this paper is to explore this particular case with a view to revealing some of the dynamics involved and challenges facing certain types of Australasian schools in the 1950s and 1960s.

Design/methodology/approach: This article is essentially founded on empirical historical research and on analysis of data from published and archival sources and from interviews with participants and observers. It is placed in the context of the literature on both educational change in Australasia and trans‐Tasman migration at the time.

Findings: Although Guthrie Wilson craved recognition as a novelist, he excelled as a school Principal, partly because he seemed to fit certain notions of education, leadership and manhood which suited the Council of The Scots College Sydney. In the 1960s, the Council wanted to maintain traditions which appeared to have been weakened by Wilson's progressive predecessor and challenged by social change. Though he fulfilled the Council's expectations, Wilson also proved to be a mediator between traditional and progressive education. Thus, Wilson could be both an honourable representative of the “Old School” and modestly progressive.

Originality/value: Biographical studies can reveal unsuspected patterns as well as challenge casual generalizations. Images of schools and of their leadership, held by both contemporaries and later observers, can prove to be subtly misleading on closer inspection. In particular, the article confronts a number of school myths which affect not only the schools involved but all schools, mutatis mutandis.

Keywordsprivate education; principals; private schools; educational philosophies; educational leadership; Trans-Tasman migration; Australia; New Zealand; manhood; school traditions; history of education
Year2013
JournalHistory of Education Review
Journal citation42 (1), pp. 69 - 84
PublisherEmerald Publishing Limited
ISSN0819-8691
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)https://doi.org/10.1108/08198691311317705
Scopus EID2-s2.0-84887308681
Page range69 - 84
Research GroupSchool of Arts
Place of publicationUnited Kingdom
Permalink -

https://acuresearchbank.acu.edu.au/item/8978z/guthrie-wilson-and-the-trans-tasman-educational-career

Restricted files

Publisher's version

  • 3
    total views
  • 0
    total downloads
  • 2
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month
These values are for the period from 19th October 2020, when this repository was created.

Export as

Related outputs

Methodism in New South Wales, 1855 - 1902
Prentis, Malcolm. (2015) Methodism in New South Wales, 1855 - 1902. In In G. O'Brien and H. M. Carey (Ed.). Methodism in Australia: A History pp. 29 - 44 Ashgate Publishing Limited.
Commemoration of Robert Burns in Australia and New Zealand
Prentis, Malcolm. (2012) Commemoration of Robert Burns in Australia and New Zealand [Dataset].
Reverend Samuel Marsden and the Maori Mission
Prentis, Malcolm. (2012) Reverend Samuel Marsden and the Maori Mission [Dataset].
Scotland, empire and evangelicalism: Andrew Stewart and Queensland
Prentis, Malcolm. (2012) Scotland, empire and evangelicalism: Andrew Stewart and Queensland. In M. K. Harmes, L. Henderson and B. Harmes & A. Antonio (Ed.). The British world: religion, memory, society, culture. Australia: University of Southern Queensland. pp. 255 - 264
'It's a long way to the bottom': The insignificance of 'the Scots' in Australia
Prentis, Malcolm. (2011) 'It's a long way to the bottom': The insignificance of 'the Scots' in Australia. Immigrants and Minorities. 29(2), pp. 195 - 219. https://doi.org/10.1080/02619288.2011.577597
Binding or loosing in Australasia: Some trans-Tasman protestant connections
Prentis, Malcolm. (2010) Binding or loosing in Australasia: Some trans-Tasman protestant connections. Journal of Religious History. 34(3), pp. 312 - 334. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9809.2010.00899.x
The plague in Sydney in 1900
Prentis, Malcolm. (2010) The plague in Sydney in 1900 [Dataset].
Scottishness and britishness in Australasia, 1875-1920
Prentis, Malcolm. (2010) Scottishness and britishness in Australasia, 1875-1920. Journal of the Royal Australian Historical Society. 96(2), pp. 168 - 183.
A study in black and white: The Aborigines in Australian history
Prentis, Malcolm David MacKenzie. (2009) A study in black and white: The Aborigines in Australian history Rosenberg Publishing.
The Scots in Sydney
Prentis, Malcolm. (2008) The Scots in Sydney. Sydney Journal. 1(2), pp. 81 - 89.
A concise companion to Aboriginal history
Prentis, Malcolm David MacKenzie. (2008) A concise companion to Aboriginal history Rosenberg Publishing.
Minister and dominie: Creating an Australasian Scottish world?
Prentis, Malcolm. (2008) Minister and dominie: Creating an Australasian Scottish world? Scottish Tradition (print version). 33, pp. 7 - 36.
The Scots in Australia
Prentis, Malcolm. (2008) The Scots in Australia University of New South Wales Press.
The rise and fall of a significant headmaster
Prentis, Malcolm David MacKenzie. (2007) The rise and fall of a significant headmaster. In In A. Potts and T. O'Donoghue (Ed.). Schools as Dangerous Places: A Historical Perspective pp. 189 - 212 Cambria Press.
The multicultural: Heritage of the uniting church
Prentis, Malcolm David MacKenzie. (2006) The multicultural: Heritage of the uniting church. In In H. Richmond and M.D. Yang (Ed.). Crossing Borders, Shaping Faith, Ministry and Identity in Multicultural; Australia pp. 43 - 52 UCA Assembly & NSW Board of Mission.
Architect of young lives: The rise and fall of Allen Mclucas
Prentis, Malcolm. (2004) Architect of young lives: The rise and fall of Allen Mclucas. History of Education Review. 33(1), pp. 60 - 72.
What do we know about the Scottish convicts?
Prentis, Malcolm. (2004) What do we know about the Scottish convicts? Journal of the Royal Australian Historical Society. 90(June), pp. 36 - 52.
Scottish places names in Australia
Prentis, Malcolm. (2004) Scottish places names in Australia. Australian Folklore: a yearly journal of folklore studies. 19(November), pp. 43 - 51.
Haggis on the high seas: Shipboard experiences of Scottish emigrants to Australia; 1821-1897
Prentis, Malcolm. (2004) Haggis on the high seas: Shipboard experiences of Scottish emigrants to Australia; 1821-1897. Australian Historical Studies. 36(124), pp. 294 - 311. https://doi.org/10.1080/10314610408596290
National History of Methodism In Australia
Prentis, Malcolm. (2003) National History of Methodism In Australia [Dataset].