The gospel of Matthew, John the elder and the Papias tradition: A response to R H Gundry

Journal article

Sim, David. (2007). The gospel of Matthew, John the elder and the Papias tradition: A response to R H Gundry. Hervormde Teologiese Studies. 63(1), pp. 283 - 299. https://doi.org/10.4102/hts.v63i1.200
AuthorsSim, David
Abstract

As far as the origin of the Gospel of Matthew is concerned, most modern scholars tend to discount the testimony of Papias. The major exception in this regard is R H Gundry, who argues that the tradition transmitted by Papias was delivered to him by John the disciple of Jesus. For Gundry the apostolic source of this tradition thereby guarantees its reliability, in which case we can be confident that Matthew, the disciple of Jesus, was the author of the Gospel that bears his name. Gundry's arguments are, however, not altogether convincing. It will be shown that not only is his reading of the Papian tradition questionable, but also that he overstates the reliability of Papias' source.

KeywordsTheology
Year2007
JournalHervormde Teologiese Studies
Journal citation63 (1), pp. 283 - 299
PublisherUniversity of Pretoria
ISSN0259-9422
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)https://doi.org/10.4102/hts.v63i1.200
Web address (URL)https://www.ajol.info/index.php/hts/article/view/41195
Open accessOpen access
Research or scholarlyResearch
Page range283 - 299
Research GroupSchool of Theology
Publisher's version
License
File Access Level
Open
Output statusPublished
Publication dates
Print14 Oct 2008
Publication process dates
Accepted2007
Place of publicationSouth Africa
Permalink -

https://acuresearchbank.acu.edu.au/item/8qw39/the-gospel-of-matthew-john-the-elder-and-the-papias-tradition-a-response-to-r-h-gundry

Log in to edit

Download files

Publisher's version
OA_Sim_2007_The_Gospel_of Matthew_John_the.pdf
License: CC BY 4.0
File access level: Open

  • 125
    total views
  • 24
    total downloads
  • 0
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month
These values are for the period from 19th October 2020, when this repository was created.

Export as

Related outputs

Jew Against Jew : The Reception of Paul in Matthew's Christian Jewish Community
Sim, David Campbell. (2019). Jew Against Jew : The Reception of Paul in Matthew's Christian Jewish Community. In In Boccaccini, Gabriele and Oliver, Isaac W. (Ed.). The Early Reception of Paul the Second Temple Jew: Text, Narrative and Reception History pp. 107 Bloomsbury T&T Clark. https://doi.org/10.5040/9780567675248.0014
N-terminal pro-B-type natriuretic peptide and prognosis in Caucasian vs. Asian patients with heart failure
Tromp, Jasper, Richards, Arthur Mark, Tay, Wan Ting, Teng, Tiew-Hwa Katherine, Yeo, Poh Shuan Daniel, Sim, David, Jaufeerally, Fazlur, Leong, Gerard, Ong, Hean Yee, Ling, Lieng Hsi, van Veldhuisen, Dirk J., Jaarsma, Tiny, Voors, Adriaan A., van der Meer, Peter, de Boer, Rudolf A. and Lam, Carolyn S. P.. (2018). N-terminal pro-B-type natriuretic peptide and prognosis in Caucasian vs. Asian patients with heart failure. ESC Heart Failure. 5(2), pp. 279 - 287. https://doi.org/10.1002/ehf2.12252
Baseline characteristics of patients with heart failure and preserved ejection fraction in the PARAGON-HF Trial
Solomon, Scott, Rizkala, Adel R., Lefkowitz, Martin P., Shi, Victor C., Gong, Jianjian, Anavekar, Nagesh, Anker, Stefan D., Arango, Juan Luis, Arenas, Jose L., Atar, Dan, Ben-Gal, Turia, Boytsov, Sergey, Chen, -Huan Chen, Chopra, Vijay, Cleland, John G. F., Comin-Colet, Josep, Duengen, Hans-Dirk, Exheverria Correa, Luis E., Filippatos, Gerasimos S., ... Jr, Jiří Widimský. (2018). Baseline characteristics of patients with heart failure and preserved ejection fraction in the PARAGON-HF Trial. Circulation: Heart Failure. 11(7), pp. 1 - 10. https://doi.org/10.1161/CIRCHEARTFAILURE.118.004962
The Gospel of Matthew and Galilee. An Evaluation of an Emerging Hypothesis
Sim, David Campbell. (2016). The Gospel of Matthew and Galilee. An Evaluation of an Emerging Hypothesis. Zeitschrift fur die Neutestamentliche Wissenschaft und die Kunde der Alteren Kirche. 107(2), pp. 141 - 169. https://doi.org/10.1515/znw-2016-0009
Jews, Gentiles and the ethnic identity in the Gospel of Matthew
Sim, David. (2015). Jews, Gentiles and the ethnic identity in the Gospel of Matthew. In In G. D. Dunn and W. Mayer (Ed.). Christians shaping identity from the Roman Empire to Byzantium: Studies inspired by Pauline Allen pp. 25 - 47 Koninklijke Brill NV.
The Family of Jesus and the Disciples of Jesus in Paul and Mark: Taking Sides in the Early Church's Factional Dispute
Sim, David. (2014). The Family of Jesus and the Disciples of Jesus in Paul and Mark: Taking Sides in the Early Church's Factional Dispute. In In O. Wischmeyer, D. Sim and I. Elmer (Ed.). Paul and Mark: Comparative Essays Part I Two Authors at the Beginnings of Christianity pp. 73 - 99 De Gruyter Mouton.
Is Matthew 28 : 16-20 the Summary of the Gospel?
Sim, David. (2014). Is Matthew 28 : 16-20 the Summary of the Gospel? Hervormde Teologiese Studies. 70(1), pp. 1 - 7. https://doi.org/10.4102/hts.v70i1.2756
Men and women in the Gospel of Matthew
Sim, David. (2014). Men and women in the Gospel of Matthew. In In W. Mayer and I. J. Elmer (Ed.). Men and women in the early Christian centuries pp. 55 - 71 St Pauls Publications.
The Reception of Paul and Mark in the Gospel of Matthew
Sim, David. (2014). The Reception of Paul and Mark in the Gospel of Matthew. In In O. Wischmeyer, D. Sim and I. Elmer (Ed.). Paul and Mark: Comparative Essays Part I Two Authors at the Beginnings of Christianity pp. 589 - 615 De Gruyter Mouton.
The attitude to Gentiles in the Gospel of Matthew
Sim, David. (2013). The attitude to Gentiles in the Gospel of Matthew. In In DC Sim and JS McLaren (Ed.). Attitudes to gentiles in ancient Judaism and early Christianity pp. 173 - 191 Bloomsbury T & T Clark.
Conflict in the canon: the Pauline literature and the Gospel of Matthew
Sim, David. (2013). Conflict in the canon: the Pauline literature and the Gospel of Matthew. In In W Mayer and B Neil (Ed.). Religious conflict from early Christianity to the rise of Islam pp. 71 - 87 De Gruyter.
Gentiles, God-fearers and proselytes
Sim, David. (2013). Gentiles, God-fearers and proselytes. In In DC Sim and JS McLaren (Ed.). Attitudes to gentiles in ancient Judaism and early Christianity pp. 9 - 27 Bloomsbury T & T Clark.
Jews, Christians and Gentiles: observations and some concluding remarks
Sim, David. (2013). Jews, Christians and Gentiles: observations and some concluding remarks. In In DC Sim and JS McLaren (Ed.). Attitudes to gentiles in ancient Judaism and early Christianity pp. 259 - 266 Bloomsbury T & T Clark.
Does the Gospel of Matthew presuppose a canon of scriptures?
Sim, David. (2012). Does the Gospel of Matthew presuppose a canon of scriptures? In In E. M. Becker and S. Scholz (Ed.). Kanon in Konstruktion und Dekonstruktion: Kanonisierungsprozesse religioser Texte von der Antike bis zur Gegenwart. Ein Handbuch pp. 449 - 468 Walter de Gruyter.
Fighting on all fronts: Crisis management in the Gospel of Matthew
Sim, David. (2012). Fighting on all fronts: Crisis management in the Gospel of Matthew. In In D. Sim and P. Allen (Ed.). Ancient Jewish and Christian Texts as Crisis Management Literature pp. 62 - 78 T&T Clark International.
Coping with the Present by Inventing the Future : Jewish Apocalyptic Texts as Crisis Management Literature
Sim, David. (2012). Coping with the Present by Inventing the Future : Jewish Apocalyptic Texts as Crisis Management Literature. In In D Sim and P Allen (Ed.). Ancient Jewish and Christian Texts as Crisis Management Literature pp. 29 - 45 T&T Clark International.
Fighting on All Fronts : Crisis Management in the Gospel of Matthew
Sim, David. (2012). Fighting on All Fronts : Crisis Management in the Gospel of Matthew. In In D Sim and P Allen (Ed.). Ancient Jewish and Christian Texts as Crisis Management Literature pp. 62 - 78 T&T Clark International.
Conclusions to Ancient Jewish and Christian texts as crisis management literature
Sim, David. (2012). Conclusions to Ancient Jewish and Christian texts as crisis management literature. In In D C Sim and P Allen (Ed.). Ancient Jewish and Christian Texts as Crisis Management Literature pp. 173 - 176 T&T Clark International.
Ancient Jewish and Christian texts as crisis management literature: Thematic studies from the Centre for Early Christian Studies
Sim, David C. and Allen, Pauline. (2012). Ancient Jewish and Christian texts as crisis management literature: Thematic studies from the Centre for Early Christian Studies T&T Clark International.
Matthew: The current state of research
Sim, David. (2011). Matthew: The current state of research. In In EM Becker and A Runesson (Ed.). Mark and Matthew I Comparative Readings: Understanding the Earliest Gospels in their First-Century Settings pp. 33 - 51 Mohr Siebeck.
The pacifist Jesus and the violent Jesus in the Gospel of Matthew
Sim, David C.. (2011). The pacifist Jesus and the violent Jesus in the Gospel of Matthew. Hervormde Teologiese Studies. 67(1), pp. 1 - 6. https://doi.org/10.4102/hts.v67i1.860
Polemical strategies in the Gospel of Matthew
Sim, David C.. (2011). Polemical strategies in the Gospel of Matthew. In In Oda Wischmeyer and Lorenzo Scornaienchi (Ed.). Polemik in der Fruhchristlichen Literatur: texte and kontexte pp. 475 - 491 Walter de Gruyter.
Matthew's use of Mark: Did Matthew intend to supplement or to replace his primary source?
Sim, David. (2011). Matthew's use of Mark: Did Matthew intend to supplement or to replace his primary source? New Testament Studies. 57(2), pp. 176 - 192. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0028688510000366
Matthew and the Synoptic problem
Sim, David C.. (2011). Matthew and the Synoptic problem. In In P Foster, A Gregory and JS Kloppenborg (Ed.). New Studies in the Synoptic Problem : Oxford conference, April 2008 : essays in honour of Christopher M. Tuckett pp. 187 - 208 Peeters Publishing.
The Gospels and the politics of replacement
Sim, David C.. (2010). The Gospels and the politics of replacement. In Studies of Religion and Politics in the Early Christian Centuries pp. 29 - 43 St Pauls Publications.
Jesus as role model in the gospel of Matthew: Does the Matthean Jesus practise what he preaches?
Sim, David. (2010). Jesus as role model in the gospel of Matthew: Does the Matthean Jesus practise what he preaches? Australian Ejournal of Theology. 16, pp. 1 - 21.
Matthew and the Pauline corpus: A preliminary intertextual study
Sim, David. (2009). Matthew and the Pauline corpus: A preliminary intertextual study. Journal for the Study of the New Testament. 31(4), pp. 401 - 422. https://doi.org/10.1177/0142064X09104958
Wealth and poverty in the gospel of Matthew
Sim, David Campbell. (2009). Wealth and poverty in the gospel of Matthew. In In G. D. Dunn, D. Luckensmeyer and L. Cross (Ed.). Prayer and Spirituality in the Early Church V: Poverty and Riches pp. 75 - 88 St Pauls Publications.
The rise and fall of the gospel of Matthew
Sim, David. (2009). The rise and fall of the gospel of Matthew. Expository Times. 120(10), pp. 478 - 485. https://doi.org/10.1177/0014524609106580
Paul and Matthew on the Torah: Theory and practice
Sim, David C.. (2009). Paul and Matthew on the Torah: Theory and practice. In In P. Middleton, A. Paddison and K.J. Wenell (Ed.). Paul, Grace and Freedom: Essays in honour of John K.Riches pp. 50 - 64 T&T Clark International.
The synoptic gospels
Sim, David. (2008). The synoptic gospels. Expository Times. 119(7), pp. 313 - 319. https://doi.org/10.1177/0014524608091089
Introduction
Sim, David Campbell. (2008). Introduction. In In D. Sim and B. Repschinski (Ed.). Matthew and His Christian Contemporaries pp. 1 - 10 T&T Clark International.
Reconstructing the social and religious milieu of Matthew: Methods, sources, and possible results
Sim, David C.. (2008). Reconstructing the social and religious milieu of Matthew: Methods, sources, and possible results. In In J. K. Zangenberg and H.W.M. van de Sandt (Ed.). Matthew, James and Didache: Three Related Documents in their Jewish and Christian Settings pp. 13 - 32 Society of Biblical Literature.
Matthew and Ignatious of Antioch
Sim, David Campbell. (2008). Matthew and Ignatious of Antioch. In In D. Sim and B. Repschinski (Ed.). Matthew and His Christian Contemporaries pp. 139 - 154 T&T Clark International.
Matthew and Jesus of Nazareth
Sim, David Campbell. (2008). Matthew and Jesus of Nazareth. In In D. C. Sim and B.Repschinski (Ed.). Matthew and His Christian Contemporaries pp. 155 - 172 T&T Clark International.
Jewish literature of the period
Sim, David Campbell. (2008). Jewish literature of the period. In In J. McLaren (Ed.). Judaism in Transition 175 BCE-150 CE. Christian and Jewish Perspectives pp. 15 - 30 Council of Christians and Jews.
Matthew, Paul and the origin and nature of the gentile mission: The great commission in Matthew 28:16-20 as an anti-Pauline tradition
Sim, David. (2008). Matthew, Paul and the origin and nature of the gentile mission: The great commission in Matthew 28:16-20 as an anti-Pauline tradition. Hervormde Teologiese Studies. 64(1), pp. 377 - 392. https://doi.org/10.4102/hts.v64i1.28
Matthew 7.21-23: Further evidence of its anti-Pauline perspective
Sim, David. (2007). Matthew 7.21-23: Further evidence of its anti-Pauline perspective. New Testament Studies. 53(3), pp. 325 - 343. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0028688507000161
The appearances of the risen Christ to Paul: Identifying their implications and complications
Sim, David. (2006). The appearances of the risen Christ to Paul: Identifying their implications and complications. Australian Biblical Review. 54, pp. 1 - 12.
The failed Christian mission to the Jews: A historical and theological defence of the Jewish position
Sim, David Campbell. (2006). The failed Christian mission to the Jews: A historical and theological defence of the Jewish position. In In W. Mayer, P. Allen and L. Cross (Ed.). Prayer and Spirituality in the Early Church IV: The Spiritual Life pp. 37 - 48 St Pauls Publications.
Conclusions
Sim, David Campbell. (2005). Conclusions. In In J. Riches and D. Sim (Ed.). The Gospel of Matthew in its Roman Imperial Context pp. 166 - 169 T&T Clark International.
Christian Judaism: A reconstruction and evaluation of the original Christian tradition
Sim, David Campbell. (2005). Christian Judaism: A reconstruction and evaluation of the original Christian tradition. In In E. Kessler and M.J. Wright (Ed.). Themes in Jewish Christian relations pp. 39 - 58 Orchard Academic.
Rome in Matthew’s eschatology
Sim, David Campbell. (2005). Rome in Matthew’s eschatology. In In J. Riches and D. Sim (Ed.). The Gospel of Matthew in its Roman Imperial Context pp. 91 - 106 T&T Clark International.
How many Jews became Christians in the first century? The failure of the Christian mission to the Jews
Sim, David. (2005). How many Jews became Christians in the first century? The failure of the Christian mission to the Jews. Hervormde Teologiese Studies. 61(February), pp. 417 - 440. https://doi.org/10.4102/hts.v61i1/2.430
The defensibility of Christian Judaism
Sim, David Campbell. (2003). The defensibility of Christian Judaism. In In B. Neil, G.D. Dunn and L. Cross (Ed.). Prayer and Spirituality in the Early Church III: Liturgy and Life pp. 57 - 72 St Paul's Press.
Matthew and the gentiles: A response to Brendan Byrne - and Byrne responds
Sim, David. (2002). Matthew and the gentiles: A response to Brendan Byrne - and Byrne responds. Australian Biblical Review. 50, pp. 74 - 79.
The dissection of the wicked servant in Matthew 24:51
Sim, David. (2002). The dissection of the wicked servant in Matthew 24:51. Hervormde Teologiese Studies. 58(1), pp. 172 - 184. https://doi.org/10.4102/hts.v58i1.542
Matthew's anti-Paulinism: A neglected feature of Matthean studies
Sim, David. (2002). Matthew's anti-Paulinism: A neglected feature of Matthean studies. Hervormde Teologiese Studies. 58(2), pp. 767 - 783. https://doi.org/10.4102/hts.v58i2.557