Is comparative theology Catholic? Expectations regarding the comparativist

Journal article


Clooney, Francis X.. (2014). Is comparative theology Catholic? Expectations regarding the comparativist. Studies in Interreligious Dialogue. 24(1), pp. 18 - 26. https://doi.org/10.2143/SID.24.1.3040772
AuthorsClooney, Francis X.
Abstract

Clooney’s lead article makes the case for a comparative theology that is Catholic and, consequently, for a Catholic theology that is deeply interreligious and yet still Catholic. It is fair enough to inquire into the depth of Catholicity undergirding a Catholic comparative theology even if, on the whole, comparative theology ought not to be held to a higher or stricter standard than the rest of Catholic theology. The article’s core argument is that the study of the texts of another religious tradition can and should be undertaken for the sake of Catholic theology, as a genuine form of Catholic theology. The thesis is illumined by four guiding points: discerning God’s presence in the content of non-Christian texts; discerning legitimate analogies across traditions’ boundaries, a discernment which requires theological instincts; moving from an extrinsic to an engaged form of scholarship; judging a Catholic comparative theology, like any other theology, by its fruits. On all four points, progress can be best made by the comparativist who is Catholic and thus too by a theologian genuinely engaged in the study of another religious tradition in the particular. The Catholic theologian who can learn most wisely from another religion is the Catholic who wisely studies the other tradition; and this theologian is a comparative theologian. Conversely, non- or pre-theological reading served up for subsequent theological study by others is unlikely to eventuate in a mature and integral Catholic theology. Separating theology and the study of religions does not serve the cause of theology, even if in the short run it seems to make things neater and safer. In his reply, Winkler, among other things, points to the importance of factors like the theologian’s subjective engagement and the necessity of theology of religions for doing comparative theology.

Year2014
JournalStudies in Interreligious Dialogue
Journal citation24 (1), pp. 18 - 26
PublisherPeeters Publishers
ISSN0926-2326
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)https://doi.org/10.2143/SID.24.1.3040772
Scopus EID2-s2.0-84908866263
Page range18 - 26
Publisher's version
File Access Level
Controlled
Place of publicationBelgium
Permalink -

https://acuresearchbank.acu.edu.au/item/8v1q9/is-comparative-theology-catholic-expectations-regarding-the-comparativist

Restricted files

Publisher's version

  • 114
    total views
  • 0
    total downloads
  • 0
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month
These values are for the period from 19th October 2020, when this repository was created.

Export as

Related outputs

The Use of Sanskrit as a Theological Resource in the Interpretation of TiruvāymoÏi
Clooney, Francis X.. (2015). The Use of Sanskrit as a Theological Resource in the Interpretation of TiruvāymoÏi. International Journal of Hindu Studies. 19(1-2), pp. 7 - 38. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11407-015-9170-5
In the balance: Interior and shared acts of reading
Clooney, Francis Xavier. (2013). In the balance: Interior and shared acts of reading. Modern Theology. 29(4), pp. 172 - 187. https://doi.org/10.1111/moth.12068
His hiding place is darkness: A Hindu-Catholic theopoetics of divine absence
Clooney, Francis Xavier. (2013). His hiding place is darkness: A Hindu-Catholic theopoetics of divine absence Stanford University Press.
By the power of her word: Absence, memory, and speech in the song of songs and a Hindu mystical text
Clooney, Francis Xavier. (2012). By the power of her word: Absence, memory, and speech in the song of songs and a Hindu mystical text. Exchange. 41(3), pp. 213 - 244. https://doi.org/10.1163/157254312X650577
Artful imagining: A personal insight into the study of religions after Vatican II
Clooney, Francis Xavier. (2012). Artful imagining: A personal insight into the study of religions after Vatican II. Australian Ejournal of Theology. 19(2), pp. 97 - 111.
Carefully uncertain: The limits of clarity at interreligious borders
Clooney, Francis Xavier. (2012). Carefully uncertain: The limits of clarity at interreligious borders. Common Knowledge. 18(2), pp. 312 - 324. https://doi.org/10.1215/0961754X-1544968
Learning our way: Some Catholic reflections on the Catholic-Hindu Encounter
Clooney, Francis Xavier. (2012). Learning our way: Some Catholic reflections on the Catholic-Hindu Encounter. In In J. L. Heft (Ed.). Catholicism and Interreligious Dialogue pp. 89 - 125 Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199827879.001.0001
A Catholic comparativist's view of scriptural reasoning in the Anglican context
Clooney, Francis Xavier. (2012). A Catholic comparativist's view of scriptural reasoning in the Anglican context. Journal of Anglican Studies. 11(2), pp. 217 - 232. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1740355313000181
Female beauty, female power: Seeing Devī in the Saundarya Lahari
Clooney, Francis Xavier. (2011). Female beauty, female power: Seeing Devī in the Saundarya Lahari. In In T. Pintchman and R. Sherma (Ed.). Woman and Goddess in Hinduism: Reinterpretations and Re-envisionings pp. 33 - 60 Palgrave Macmillan. https://doi.org/10.1057/9780230119925_3
Food, the guest, and the Taittiriya Upanishad: Hospitality in the Hindu traditions
Clooney, Francis Xavier. (2011). Food, the guest, and the Taittiriya Upanishad: Hospitality in the Hindu traditions. In In R. Kearney and J. Taylor (Ed.). Hosting the Stranger: Between Religions pp. 139 - 145 Continuum International Publishing Group Ltd.
Comparative theology - As theology
Clooney, Francis Xavier. (2011). Comparative theology - As theology. In In D. Cheetham, U. Winkler and O. R. N, Leirvik (Ed.). Interreligious Hermeneutics in Pluralistic Europe : Between Texts and People pp. 131 - 147 Rodopi.
Trinity and Hinduism
Clooney, Francis Xavier. (2011). Trinity and Hinduism. In In P. C. Phan (Ed.). The Cambridge Companion to the Trinity pp. 309 - 324 Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/CCOL9780521877398.018
Encountering the Divine Mother in Hindu and Christian hymns
Clooney, Francis Xavier. (2010). Encountering the Divine Mother in Hindu and Christian hymns. In In E. Rizo-Patron and R. Kearney (Ed.). Traversing the heart: Journeys of the inter-religious imagination pp. 235 - 247 Brill.
Comparative theology: Deep learning across religious borders
Clooney, Francis Xavier. (2010). Comparative theology: Deep learning across religious borders Wiley-Blackwell.
Beyond my God, with God's blessing
Clooney, Francis Xavier. (2009). Beyond my God, with God's blessing. In In J. Cornwell and M. McGhee (Ed.). Philosophers and God: At the Frontiers of Faith and Reason pp. 87 - 96
Tradition and dialogue: reflections on Ravi Gupta's - Walking a Theological Tightrope
Clooney, Francis. (2009). Tradition and dialogue: reflections on Ravi Gupta's - Walking a Theological Tightrope. In ISKCON Studies 1:1 pp. 1 - 13 Lulu Press, Inc.
The truth, the way, the life: Christian commentary on the three holy mantras of the Srivaisnava Hindus
Clooney, Francis. (2008). The truth, the way, the life: Christian commentary on the three holy mantras of the Srivaisnava Hindus Peeters Publishers.
Divine absence and the purification of desire: A Hindu saint's experience of a God who keeps his distance
Clooney, Francis. (2008). Divine absence and the purification of desire: A Hindu saint's experience of a God who keeps his distance. In In J.Bawker (Ed.). Knowing the Unknowable: Science and Religions on God and the Universe pp. 227 - 255 I.B. Tauris.
Augustine, apuleius, and hermes trismegistus: The City of God and advice on how (not) to read Hindu texts
Clooney, Francis Xavier. (2008). Augustine, apuleius, and hermes trismegistus: The City of God and advice on how (not) to read Hindu texts. In In B. Brown, J. Doody and K. Paffenroth (Ed.). Augustine and World Religions pp. 141 - 172
For your own good: Suffering and evil in God's plan according to one Hindu theologian
Clooney, Francis Xavier. (2008). For your own good: Suffering and evil in God's plan according to one Hindu theologian. In In M. D. Eckel and B. L. Herling (Ed.). Deliver Us From Evil pp. 169 - 185 Continuum International Publishing Group.
Beyond compare: St. Francis de Sales and Sri Vedanta Desika on loving surrender to God
Clooney, Francis Xavier. (2008). Beyond compare: St. Francis de Sales and Sri Vedanta Desika on loving surrender to God Georgetown University Press.
The future of the Harvard Theological Review in a global and interreligious age
Clooney, Francis Xavier. (2008). The future of the Harvard Theological Review in a global and interreligious age. Harvard Theological Review. 101(3-4), pp. 339 - 349. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0017816008001880
Reengaging the classical traditions in light of popular and subaltern Hinduism: Extending Felix Wilfred's reconsideration of Hindu-Christian relations
Clooney, Francis Xavier. (2008). Reengaging the classical traditions in light of popular and subaltern Hinduism: Extending Felix Wilfred's reconsideration of Hindu-Christian relations. In In P. Gnanapragasam (Ed.). Negotiating Borders: Theological Explorations in the Global Era : Essays in Honour of Prof. Felix Wilfred pp. 415 - 427
Imago dei, paramam samyam: Hindu light on a traditional christian theme
Clooney, Francis Xavier. (2008). Imago dei, paramam samyam: Hindu light on a traditional christian theme. International Journal of Hindu Studies. 12, pp. 227 - 255. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11407-008-9063-y