School-based physical activity does not compromise children's academic performance
Ahamed, Yasmin MacDonald, Heather Reed, Katherine Naylor, Patti-Jean Liu-Ambrose, Teresa McKay, Heather
Ahamed, Yasmin
MacDonald, Heather
Reed, Katherine
Naylor, Patti-Jean
Liu-Ambrose, Teresa
McKay, Heather
Abstract
Purpose: The purpose of this study was twofold: 1) to evaluate the effectiveness of a school-based physical activity intervention, Action Schools! BC (AS! BC), for maintaining academic performance in a multiethnic group of elementary children, and 2) to determine whether boys and girls' academic performance changed similarly after participation in AS! BC.
Methods: This was a 16-month cluster randomized controlled trial. Ten schools were randomized to intervention (INT) or usual practice (UP). One INT school administered the wrong final test, and one UP school graded their own test, so both were excluded. Thus, eight schools (six INT, two UP) were included in the final analysis. Children (143 boys, 144 girls) in grades 4 and 5 were recruited for the study. We used the Canadian Achievement Test (CAT-3) to evaluate academic performance (TotScore). Weekly teacher activity logs determined amounts of physical activity delivered by teachers to students. Physical activity was determined with the Physical Activity Questionnaire for Children (PAQ-C). Independent t-tests compared descriptive variables between groups and between boys and girls. We used a mixed linear model to evaluate differences in TotScore at follow-up between groups and between girls and boys.
Results: Physical activity delivered by teachers to children in INT schools was increased by 47 min·wk−1 (139 ± 62 vs 92 ± 45, P < 0.001). Participants attending UP schools had significantly higher baseline TotScores than those attending INT schools. Despite this, there was no significant difference in TotScore between groups at follow-up and between boys and girls at baseline and follow-up.
Conclusion: The AS! BC model is an attractive and feasible intervention to increase physical activity for students while maintaining levels of academic performance.
Keywords
Date
2007
Type
Journal article
Journal
Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise
Book
Volume
39
Issue
2
Page Range
371-376