Is the saving of embryos by altruistic surrogacy morally wrong?

Journal article

Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) T.. (2006). Is the saving of embryos by altruistic surrogacy morally wrong? Australian Ejournal of Theology.
AuthorsOzoliņš, Jānis (John) T.
Abstract

One of the outcomes of IVF is that it produces a surplus of embryos that in many cases are unwanted once couples succeed in having a child. These embryos either remain in suspended animation or are thawed and allowed to die. Another possibility is for them to be adopted and be implanted into a surrogate and so be brought to term. There has been no consensus amongst Catholic bioethicists about the morality of embryo adoption, with some arguing for its moral licitness, while others have argued against it. This paper argues that in some cases embryo adoption – altruistic surrogacy – is not morally wrong. These cases, however, are quite limited and involve a preparedness for lifelong commitment to the child brought to term by this process. It is argued that some arguments against embryo adoption employ an equivocation about such terms as impregnation and hence fail.

Year2006
JournalAustralian Ejournal of Theology
PublisherAustralian Catholic University
ISSN1448-6326
Open accessOpen access
Page range2 - 20
Research GroupSchool of Philosophy
Publisher's version
Place of publicationAustralia
Permalink -

https://acuresearchbank.acu.edu.au/item/88v6y/is-the-saving-of-embryos-by-altruistic-surrogacy-morally-wrong

Log in to edit

Download files

Publisher's version
OA_Ozolins_2006_Is_the_saving_of_embryos_by.pdf

  • 93
    total views
  • 76
    total downloads
  • 1
    views this month
  • 1
    downloads this month
These values are for the period from 19th October 2020, when this repository was created.

Export as

Related outputs

Body, mind, and spirit Education, gender wars, and personal identity
Ozoliņš, John. (2021). Body, mind, and spirit Education, gender wars, and personal identity. In The Body, Embodiment, and Education: An Interdisciplinary Approach pp. 12-40 Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003142010-2
Creating the civil society east and west: relationality, responsibility and the education of the humane person
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) Tālivaldis. (2017). Creating the civil society east and west: relationality, responsibility and the education of the humane person. Educational Philosophy and Theory. 49(4), pp. 362 - 378. https://doi.org/10.1080/00131857.2015.1048666
A narrative approach exploring philosophy in education and educational research
Stolz, Steven A. and Ozoliņš, Jānis T.. (2017). A narrative approach exploring philosophy in education and educational research. Educational Studies. 44(5), pp. 578 - 593. https://doi.org/10.1080/03055698.2017.1388215
God and conceptions of immanence and transcendence in Aquinas and Mengzi
Ozoliņš, Jānis Tālivaldis. (2016). God and conceptions of immanence and transcendence in Aquinas and Mengzi. In In Ozoliņš, Jānis Tālivaldis (Ed.). Religion and culture in dialogue: East and West Perspectives pp. 95 - 110 Springer.
The hermeneutics of ethical research: A case study of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities
Ozoliņš, Jānis Tālivaldis. (2016). The hermeneutics of ethical research: A case study of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities. In N. A. Irudayadason (Ed.). India: Christian World imprints. pp. 91 - 108
Proglomena: Globalisation, cultural identity and diversity
Ozoliņš, Jānis Tālivaldis. (2016). Proglomena: Globalisation, cultural identity and diversity. In In J. T. Ozoliņš (Ed.). Religion and culture in dialogue: East and West Perspectives pp. 1 - 14 Springer.
Reclaiming Paedeia in an Age of Crises : Education and the Necessity of Wisdom
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) Tālivaldis. (2015). Reclaiming Paedeia in an Age of Crises : Education and the Necessity of Wisdom. Educational Philosophy and Theory. 47(9), pp. 870 - 882. https://doi.org/10.1080/00131857.2015.1035154
Personhood and human dignity
Kirchhoffer, David, Ozoliņš, Jãnis T. and Grainger, Joanne. (2015). Personhood and human dignity. In In J. T. Ozoliņš and J. Grainger (Ed.). Foundations of Healthcare Ethics: Theory to Practice pp. 51 - 69 Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9781107589834.004
On the possibility of religious knowledge and the necessity of religious education
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) Tālivaldis. (2014). On the possibility of religious knowledge and the necessity of religious education. Res Disputandae. 20, pp. 36 - 65.
What in the world is intercultural philosophy? A reflection
Ozoliņš, Jānis Tālivaldis. (2014). What in the world is intercultural philosophy? A reflection. In In Sweet, W. (Ed.). What is intercultural philosophy? pp. 19 - 37 The Council for Research in Values and Philosophy.
Jacques Maritain and Critical Realism as a Feature of Philosophy in the Catholic Tradition
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) Tālivaldis. (2014). Jacques Maritain and Critical Realism as a Feature of Philosophy in the Catholic Tradition. In In Duma, T., Maryniarczyk, A. and Sulenta, P. (Ed.). Szutka i Realism (Art and Reality) pp. 609 - 623 KUL - The John Paul II Catholic University of Lubin.
R.S. Peters and J.H. Newman on aims of education
Ozoliņš, Janis (John). (2013). R.S. Peters and J.H. Newman on aims of education. Educational Philosophy and Theory. 45(2), pp. 153 - 170. https://doi.org/10.1080/00131857.2012.752990
A.D. Sertillanges on wisdom and the intellectual life
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) Tālivaldis. (2013). A.D. Sertillanges on wisdom and the intellectual life. Res Disputandae. 19, pp. 61 - 77.
Aquinas and his understanding of teaching and learning
Ozoliņš, Jānis Tālivaldis. (2013). Aquinas and his understanding of teaching and learning. In In Mooney, T. B. and Nowacki, M. (Ed.). Aquinas, education and the East pp. 9 - 25 Springer.
The body and the place of physical activity in education: Some classical perspectives
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John). (2013). The body and the place of physical activity in education: Some classical perspectives. Educational Philosophy and Theory. 45(9), pp. 892 - 907. https://doi.org/10.1080/00131857.2013.785356
Au coeur d'une société séculière: Quelle visibilité peut se permettre d'avoir une Université Catholique?
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John). (2013). Au coeur d'une société séculière: Quelle visibilité peut se permettre d'avoir une Université Catholique? Annales de l'ICES. 3, pp. 207 - 228.
Rola autorytetu w etyce (The role of authority in ethics)
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John). (2012). Rola autorytetu w etyce (The role of authority in ethics). Czlowiek w kulturze. 22, pp. 45 - 65.
Newman and the Idea of a University
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) Tālivaldis. (2012). Newman and the Idea of a University. Etudes newmaniennes. 28, pp. 97 - 117.
Latvia's future in the time of crisis: Is there a prospect for hope?
Ozoliņš, Jānis. (2012). Latvia's future in the time of crisis: Is there a prospect for hope? In In Kule, M. (Ed.). Modernitates veidosanas Latvija filosofiskaja un ideju vestures skatijuma: Idejas un teorijas pp. 89 - 108 University of Latvia Institute of Philosophy and Socio....
Peer review : A Key Component of the Reseach Ethics Approval Process
Ozoliņš, Jānis Tālivaldis. (2012). Peer review : A Key Component of the Reseach Ethics Approval Process. In In Vijupe, L., Kulis, M. and Dundurs, M. (Ed.). Zinatnieka Etika: Latvija, Baltija, Eiropa [Ethics of a Scientist: Latvia, Baltics, Europe] pp. 60 - 81 University of Latvia Institute of Philosophy and Socio....
Thomism and East Asian Philosophy: Comparing Aquinas and Mengzi on Human nature
Ozoliņš, Jānis. (2012). Thomism and East Asian Philosophy: Comparing Aquinas and Mengzi on Human nature. In In A Co and P Bolanos (Ed.). Thomism and East Asian Cultures: Celebrating 400 Years of Dialogue Across Civilizations pp. 55 - 68 University of Santo Tomas Publishing House.
What makes a Catholic University Catholic?
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John). (2012). What makes a Catholic University Catholic? Ethics Education. 18(1 and 2), pp. 77 - 93.
What is research ethics?
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John). (2011). What is research ethics? Ethics Education. 17(1), pp. 32 - 49.
A Christian Perspective on the Consumer Society
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) Tālivaldis. (2011). A Christian Perspective on the Consumer Society. In In Buksinski, T. (Ed.). Religions in the Public Spheres pp. 115 - 134 Peter Lang Publishing.
Ethics in a globalized world
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John). (2011). Ethics in a globalized world. In Globalization: an interdisciplinary perspective Institut Catholique d'Etudes Superieures.
Dementia and empathy: A Steinian perspective
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John). (2011). Dementia and empathy: A Steinian perspective. Ethics Education. 17(2), pp. 25 - 35.
The international theological commission and its new look at natural law
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John). (2010). The international theological commission and its new look at natural law. Ethics Education: a journal for applied philosophy and ethics in the Christian tradition. 16(2), pp. 13 - 34.
Religion, science and the culture of credulity
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John). (2010). Religion, science and the culture of credulity. Philosophy Culture and Traditions. 5, pp. 11 - 29.
Universal values and harmony between peoples
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John). (2010). Universal values and harmony between peoples. Ethics Education: a journal for applied philosophy and ethics in the Christian tradition. 16(1), pp. 20 - 39.
The natural law tradition: Introduction
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John). (2010). The natural law tradition: Introduction. Ethics Education: a journal for applied philosophy and ethics in the Christian tradition. 16(2), pp. 5 - 12.
Popper's Third World: Moral Habits and Moral Habitat
Ozoliņš, J. T.. (2010). Popper's Third World: Moral Habits and Moral Habitat. Educational Philosophy and Theory. 42(7). https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1469-5812.2008.00433.x
Liberal arts, generic skills and the aims of education
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) Tālivaldis. (2010). Liberal arts, generic skills and the aims of education. In B. Haynes (Ed.). Australia: Philosophy of Education Society of Australasia.
Poppers third world: Moral habits, moral habitat and their maintenance
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) T.. (2010). Poppers third world: Moral habits, moral habitat and their maintenance. Educational Philosophy and Theory. 42(7), pp. 742 - 761. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1469-5812.2008.00433.x
Creating public values: Schools as moral habitats
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) T.. (2010). Creating public values: Schools as moral habitats. Educational Philosophy and Theory. 42(4), pp. 410 - 423. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1469-5812.2008.00491.x
Degisen Bir Dunyada Kuresellesme, Egitim ve Degerler (Globalisation, Education and Values in a Changing World)
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) T.. (2010). Degisen Bir Dunyada Kuresellesme, Egitim ve Degerler (Globalisation, Education and Values in a Changing World). In In Rahman, A. H. (Ed.). Kuresellesme Surecinde Egitim Sorunlarinin Felsefi Boyutu: Philosophical Dimension of Educational Problems in the Globalization Process pp. 98 - 107 Egitim-Bir Sen.
Philosophy of Education and its place in the Academy
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) Tālivaldis. (2009). Philosophy of Education and its place in the Academy. 2008 Philosophy of Education Society of Australasia (PESA) Conference Proceedings. Brisbane, Australia: Queensland University of Technology. pp. 1 - 9
Human beings as resources: The ethics of buying and selling human tissues and organs
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) T.. (2009). Human beings as resources: The ethics of buying and selling human tissues and organs. Ethics Education: a journal for applied philosophy and ethics in the Christian tradition. 15(1), pp. 5 - 19.
La etica en un mundo de globalizado
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) T.. (2009). La etica en un mundo de globalizado. In In J. Camacho (Ed.). Efectos de la Globalizacion: un enfoque interdisciplinar pp. 21 - 33 Universidad Santo Tomas Colombia.
On the Possibility of Religious Knowledge
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) Tālivaldis. (2009). On the Possibility of Religious Knowledge. 37th Philosophy of Education Society of Australasia Conference 2008: The Ownership and Dissemination of Knowledge. Brisbane, Australia: Queensland University of Technology.
Guerra justa. Soberania y guerra justa
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) Tālivaldis. (2009). Guerra justa. Soberania y guerra justa. In In J. Camacho (Ed.). Efectos de la Globalizacion: un enfoque interdisciplinar pp. 186 - 196 Universidad Santo Tomas Colombia.
A response to the era paper
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) T.. (2008). A response to the era paper. Educational Philosophy and Theory. 40(7), pp. 816 - 818. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1469-5812.2008.00513.x
Globalisation, citizenship and Latvian identity in a time of change
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) T.. (2008). Globalisation, citizenship and Latvian identity in a time of change. Humanities and Social Sciences Latvia. 55(2), pp. 75 - 95.
Is the anthropic principle a poor man's intelligent design?
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) T.. (2008). Is the anthropic principle a poor man's intelligent design? Ethics Education: a journal for applied philosophy and ethics in the Christian tradition. 14(1), pp. 25 - 37.
Avoiding bad company: The importance of moral habitat and moral habits in moral education
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) T.. (2007). Avoiding bad company: The importance of moral habitat and moral habits in moral education. In In Aspin, D. and Chapman, J. (Ed.). Values Education and Lifelong Learning: Principles, Policies, Programmes pp. 107 - 126 Springer.
Spirituality- a conceptual analysis
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) T.. (2007). Spirituality- a conceptual analysis. Ethics Education: a journal for applied philosophy and ethics in the Christian tradition. 13(1), pp. 21 - 32.
A brief survey of Australian philosophy
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) Tālivaldis. (2007). A brief survey of Australian philosophy. In In M. Kule and Maija (Ed.). Philosophy Worldwide: Current Situation, Materials for International Cooperation and philosophical Encounters pp. 220 - 236 University of Latvia Institute of Philosophy and Sociology.
Creativity, education and subversion of the state
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) Tālivaldis. (2007). Creativity, education and subversion of the state. In Robert Shaw and John Codd (Ed.). Creativity, Enterprise, Policy - New Directions in Education. Proceedings of the 2007 Conference of the Philosophy of Education Society of Australasia. Wellington, New Zealand: Philosophy of Education Society of Australasia. pp. 1 - 14
Mohammed; multiculturalism and cartoons
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) T.. (2006). Mohammed; multiculturalism and cartoons. Ethics Education: a journal for applied philosophy and ethics in the Christian tradition. 12(2), pp. 4 - 12.
Education as encounter
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) Tālivaldis. (2006). Education as encounter. In In J. David and G.Evans (Ed.). Proceedings of the Twenty-First World Congress of Philosophy; Vol.4 Philosophy of Education pp. 111 - 115 Turkish Society of Philosophy.
Brothers and sisters together :On the idea of a common human nature
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) Tālivaldis. (2006). Brothers and sisters together :On the idea of a common human nature. In M. Freund, J.Mackenzie and M.O'Laughlin (Ed.). 35th Annual Conference of the Philosophy of Education Society of Australasia. Sydney, Australia: Philosophy of Education Society of Australasia.
The second draft of the national statement on ethical conduct in human research a response and discussion
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) T.. (2006). The second draft of the national statement on ethical conduct in human research a response and discussion. Ethics Education: a journal for applied philosophy and ethics in the Christian tradition. 12(1), pp. 18 - 36.
Teaching ethics in higher education:
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) Tālivaldis. (2005). Teaching ethics in higher education: In In A. Brewer and C. Asmar (Ed.). Higher Education; in a Changing World: Research and Development in Higher Education pp. 358 - 364 Higher Education Research and Development Society of Australasia.
Locating the self: Community; relationships and identity
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) T.. (2005). Locating the self: Community; relationships and identity. Philosophy Culture and Traditions. 3, pp. 1 - 13.
Popper's Third World; Moral Habits and Moral Habitat
Jānis (John) T.. (2005). Popper's Third World; Moral Habits and Moral Habitat. 34th Annual Philosophy of Education Society Australasia Conference. Hong Kong, China: Philosophy of Education Society of Australasia. pp. 376 - 388
Latviska identitate Australija: Filosofiskas pardomas (Latvian identity in Australia: a philosophical reflection)
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) Tālivaldis. (2004). Latviska identitate Australija: Filosofiskas pardomas (Latvian identity in Australia: a philosophical reflection). In In Kule, M. (Ed.). Filosofija Almanahs 4 pp. 178 - 190 University of Latvia Institute of Philosophy and Sociology.
Debating educational values: Good citizen or good person?
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) Tālivaldis. (2004). Debating educational values: Good citizen or good person? In John Ozolins (Ed.). 33rd Annual PESA Conference Education and Values: Refereed Conference Proceedings. Melbourne, Australia: Philosophy of Education Society of Australasia. pp. 97 - 106
Whose faith? Which reason?
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) Tālivaldis. (2004). Whose faith? Which reason? In In Fisher OP, A. and Ramsay, H. (Ed.). Faith and Reason: Friends or Foes in the New Millennium pp. 187 - 214 Australian Theological Forum Press.
Boat people: Why the queue jumping argument fails
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) T.. (2004). Boat people: Why the queue jumping argument fails. Australian Ejournal of Theology. August(3), pp. 1 - 23.
Justice and virtue: Critiquing communitarianism
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) T.. (2004). Justice and virtue: Critiquing communitarianism. Ethics Education: a journal for applied philosophy and ethics in the Christian tradition. 10(2), pp. 2 - 9.
Love your enemies
Ozoliņš, Jānis (John) T.. (2003). Love your enemies. Compass: a review of topical theology. 37(Winter), pp. 29 - 31.