Longitudinal sex differences of externalising and internalising depression symptom trajectories : Implications for assessment of depression in men from an online study

Journal article


Rice, Simon, Fallon, Barry, Aucote, Helen, Moller-Leimkuhler, AnneMaria, Treeby, Matt and Amminger, G.. (2015). Longitudinal sex differences of externalising and internalising depression symptom trajectories : Implications for assessment of depression in men from an online study. International Journal of Social Psychiatry. 61(3), pp. 236 - 240. https://doi.org/10.1177/0020764014540149
AuthorsRice, Simon, Fallon, Barry, Aucote, Helen, Moller-Leimkuhler, AnneMaria, Treeby, Matt and Amminger, G.
Abstract

Background: Clinical reports indicate that men tend to engage in a range of externalising behaviours in response to negative emotional states. Such externalising behaviours have been theorised to reflect a male sub-type of depression that is inconsistent with current diagnostic criteria, resulting in impeded detection and treatment rates of depressed men. Aims: In addressing previous study design limitations, this article presents self-report longitudinal data for the multidimensional Male Depression Risk Scale (MDRS-22) against ratings of diagnostic criteria for major depressive disorder as assessed by the Patient Health Questionnaire–Depression Module (PHQ-9). Longitudinal psychometric properties of the MDRS-22 are reported and symptom trajectories described. Method: A sample of 233 adults (males = 125; 54%) completed measures of externalising and prototypic depression symptoms at Time 1, and again at Time 2 (15 weeks later). Psychometric properties were examined and within-subjects analyses undertaken. Results: The MDRS-22 demonstrated stable internal consistency and test–retest correlations equivalent to those observed for the PHQ-9. Both prototypic and externalising depression symptoms increased with experiences of recent negative life events. Marked gender differences were observed. Males experiencing ≥ 2 stressful negative life events reported significantly higher MDRS-22 scores at both Time 1 and Time 2 relative to comparable females. Conclusion: Findings contribute to the validity of the MDRS-22 as a measure of externalising depression symptoms. Results suggest that while both males and females experience externalising depression symptoms, these symptoms may be particularly elevated for men following experiences of negative life events. Findings suggest that externalising symptoms may be a special feature of depression for men. Given the problematic nature of such externalising symptoms (e.g. excessive substance use, aggression, risk-taking), their clinical assessment appears warranted.

Year2015
JournalInternational Journal of Social Psychiatry
Journal citation61 (3), pp. 236 - 240
ISSN0020-7640
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)https://doi.org/10.1177/0020764014540149
Page range236 - 240
Research GroupSchool of Philosophy
Publisher's version
File Access Level
Controlled
Permalink -

https://acuresearchbank.acu.edu.au/item/85407/longitudinal-sex-differences-of-externalising-and-internalising-depression-symptom-trajectories-implications-for-assessment-of-depression-in-men-from-an-online-study

Restricted files

Publisher's version

  • 16
    total views
  • 0
    total downloads
  • 2
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month
These values are for the period from 19th October 2020, when this repository was created.

Export as

Related outputs

Prevalence and Co-Occurrence of Internalizing and Externalizing Depression Symptoms in a Community Sample of Australian Male Truck Drivers
Simon Rice, Helen Aucote, Dina Eleftheriadis and Anne Moller-Leimkuhler. (2018). Prevalence and Co-Occurrence of Internalizing and Externalizing Depression Symptoms in a Community Sample of Australian Male Truck Drivers. American Journal of Men's Health. 12(1), pp. 74-77. https://doi.org/10.1177/1557988315626262
Co-morbid depression and chronic illness related to coping and physical and mental health status
Benedetto, Mirella, Lindner, Helen, Aucote, Helen, Churcher, Jacqui, McKenzie, Stephen, Croning, Natalie and Jenkins, Erin. (2014). Co-morbid depression and chronic illness related to coping and physical and mental health status. Psychology, Health & Medicine. 19(3), pp. 253 - 262. https://doi.org/10.1080/13548506.2013.803135
Development and preliminary validation of the male depression risk scale : Furthering the assessment of depression in men
Rice, Simon, Fallon, Barry John, Aucote, Helen and Moller-Leimkuhler, Anne. (2013). Development and preliminary validation of the male depression risk scale : Furthering the assessment of depression in men. Journal of Affective Disorders. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jad.2013.08.013
Interpretation and misinterpretation of warning signage : Perceptions of rockfalls in a naturalistic setting
Aucote, Helen, Miner, Anthony and Dahlhaus, Peter. (2012). Interpretation and misinterpretation of warning signage : Perceptions of rockfalls in a naturalistic setting. Psychology, Health & Medicine. 17(5), pp. 522 - 529. https://doi.org/10.1080/13548506.2011.644247
Interpersonal factors as precipitators of crisis: A focus on ministers of religion
Fallon, Barry J. and Rice, Simon M.. (2010). Interpersonal factors as precipitators of crisis: A focus on ministers of religion. 10th Annual Conference of the Australian Psychological Society's Psychology of Relationships Interest Group. Australia: Australian Psychological Society. pp. 15 - 21
The effect of non-standard work hours on a couple's relationship
Stevens, Catherine and Fallon, Barry J.. (2010). The effect of non-standard work hours on a couple's relationship. Building Resilience Through Personal, Family, and Community Relationships.. Australia: Australian Psychological Society. pp. 40 - 45
The wheels keep turning: Associations between relationship status and male depression in truck drivers
Rice, Simon M. and Fallon, Barry J.. (2010). The wheels keep turning: Associations between relationship status and male depression in truck drivers. In T. Djokic (Ed.). 10th Annual Conference of the Australian Psychological Society's Psychology of Relationships Interest Group, Queensland University of Technology, Brisbane Australia, 6 - 7 November 2010. Melbourne, Australia: The Australian Psychological Society. pp. 34 - 39
Rockfalls: Predicting high risk behaviours from beliefs
Aucote, Helen, Miner, Anthony and Dahlhaus, Peter. (2010). Rockfalls: Predicting high risk behaviours from beliefs. Disaster Prevention and Management: an international journal. 19(1), pp. 20 - 31. https://doi.org/10.1108/09653561011022117
Falling apart after a broken heart: Association between gender, relationship status, recency of separation and depression
Moore, Daniel R., Rice, Simon M. and Fallon, Barry J.. (2010). Falling apart after a broken heart: Association between gender, relationship status, recency of separation and depression. 10th Annual Conference of the Australian Psychological Society's Psychology of Relationships Interest Group. Australia: Australian Psychological Society. pp. 22 - 27
Relationships during young adulthood: The impact of relationship tension on strength and reward
Rice, Simon M., Smith, Rosanne Burton and Fallon, Barry John. (2009). Relationships during young adulthood: The impact of relationship tension on strength and reward. In Z. J .Hazelwood (Ed.). 9th Annual Conference of the Australian Psychological Society's Psychology of Relationships Interest Group. Melbourne, Australia: Australian Psychological Society. pp. 42 - 47
Measuring the psychological consequences of breast cancer screening: A confirmatory factor analysis of the psychological consequences questionnaire
Cooper, Andrew and Aucote, Helen. (2009). Measuring the psychological consequences of breast cancer screening: A confirmatory factor analysis of the psychological consequences questionnaire. Quality of Life Research. 18(5), pp. 597 - 604. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11136-009-9472-4
Male depression: The impact of masculine role norms
Rice, Simon and Fallon, Barry John. (2009). Male depression: The impact of masculine role norms. In Nicholas Voudouris and Vicky Mrowinski (Ed.). 44th APS Annual Conference. Melbourne,Australia: Australian Psychological Society. pp. 145 - 149
How does having a partner affect the experience of the work-life interface for mothers: Self-efficacy, coping and support
Fallon, Barry John and Anglicas, Mary. (2009). How does having a partner affect the experience of the work-life interface for mothers: Self-efficacy, coping and support. In N. Voudouris and V. Mrowinski (Ed.). 44th APS Annual Conference. Melbourne, Australia: Australian Psychological Society. pp. 56 - 61
Workplace justice and intention to quit :Generational differences
Fallon, Barry John and Mawdsley, Caroline. (2008). Workplace justice and intention to quit :Generational differences. In Dr Zoe Pearce (Ed.). Melbourne, Australia: Australian Psychological Society. pp. 14 - 19
Investigating gender differences in depression ratings according to relationship status
Rice, Simon and Fallon, Barry John. (2008). Investigating gender differences in depression ratings according to relationship status. In Zoe Pearce (Ed.). The 8th Annual Conference of the Australian Psychological Society's Psychology of Relationshps Interest Group. Melbourne, Australia: Australian Psychological Society. pp. 33 - 39
Y's, X's, & Boomers :Do they differ with respect to critical organisational variables
Caballero, Catherine and Fallon, Barry John. (2008). Y's, X's, & Boomers :Do they differ with respect to critical organisational variables. In Nicholas Voudouris and Vicky Mrowninski (Ed.). Melbourne, Australia: Australian Psychological Society. pp. 154 - 158
Changing perception of average person's risk does not suffice to change perception of comparative risk
Aucote, Helen and Gold, Ron. (2008). Changing perception of average person's risk does not suffice to change perception of comparative risk. Psychology, Health & Medicine. 13(4), pp. 461 - 470. https://doi.org/10.1080/13548500701694227
The behavioural inhibition system and behavioural approach system (bis/bas) scales: Measurement and structural invariance across adults and adolescents
Cooper, Andrew, Gomez, Rapson and Aucote, Helen. (2007). The behavioural inhibition system and behavioural approach system (bis/bas) scales: Measurement and structural invariance across adults and adolescents. Personality and Individual Differences. 43(2), pp. 295 - 305. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.paid.2006.11.023
Workaholism among Australian female managers and professionals: Job behaviours, satisfaction and psychological health
Fallon, Barry, Burke, Robert and Burgess, Zena. (2006). Workaholism among Australian female managers and professionals: Job behaviours, satisfaction and psychological health. Equality, Diversity and Inclusion: An International Journal. 25(3), pp. 200 - 213.
Organizational practices supporting women and their satisfaction and well-being
Fallon, Barry, Burke, Robert and Burgess, Zena. (2006). Organizational practices supporting women and their satisfaction and well-being. Gender in Management: An International Journal. 21(5), pp. 416 - 425. https://doi.org/10.1108/09649420610676217
Benefits of mentoring to Australian early career women managers and professionals
Fallon, Barry, Burke, Robert and Burgess, Zena. (2006). Benefits of mentoring to Australian early career women managers and professionals. Equality, Diversity and Inclusion: An International Journal. 25(1), pp. 71 - 79.
Are conflict resolution styles related to conflict dimensions and conflict outcome satisfaction
Bowles, Terence Victor and Fallon, Barry John. (2006). Are conflict resolution styles related to conflict dimensions and conflict outcome satisfaction. In T Bowles.V. (Ed.). Relationships Near and Far: 6th Annual Conference of the APS Interest Group on the Psychology of Relationships. Melbourne ,Australia: Australian Psychological Society. pp. 42 - 48
Changing and coping, and the stimulus to change from an adolescent perspective: A replication of adult research
Bowles, Terry and Fallon, Barry. (2006). Changing and coping, and the stimulus to change from an adolescent perspective: A replication of adult research. Australian Journal of Psychology. 58(1), pp. 8 - 15. https://doi.org/10.1080/00049530500230999
Do women directors have to join the boys club?
Fallon, Barry John and Burgess, Zena. (2005). Do women directors have to join the boys club? In T Bowles (Ed.). 5th Annual Conference of the Australian Psychological Society's Psychology of Relationships Interest Group: The good; the bad; and the ugly in personal; national and international relationships. Melbourne, Australia: Australian Psychological Society. pp. 31 - 35
Relationship rules: A conceptual model of rule-setting and rule violations in romantic relationships
Fallon, Barry John and West, Alexandra Elizabeth. (2005). Relationship rules: A conceptual model of rule-setting and rule violations in romantic relationships. In Dr Mary Katsikitis (Ed.). The 40th Australian Psychological Society Annual Conference: Past reflections, Future directions. Melbourne, Australia: Australian Psychological Society. pp. 372 - 376
Is my trust towards the one I love related to my attachment style?
Fallon, Barry John and Holt, Christopher. (2005). Is my trust towards the one I love related to my attachment style? In T Bowles. (Ed.). 5th Annual Conference of the Australian Psychological Society's Psychology of Relationships Interest Group. Melbourne, Australia: Australian Psychological Society. pp. 80 - 85
Rule-setting and rule-breaking: A conceptual model of rules and expectations in romantic relationships
West, Alexandra Elizabeth and Fallon, Barry John. (2005). Rule-setting and rule-breaking: A conceptual model of rules and expectations in romantic relationships. In Terry Bowles and Zoe Pearce (Ed.). 5th Annual Conference of the Australian Psychological Society's Psychology of Relationships Interest Group: The good; the bad; and the ugly in personal; national and international relationships. Melbourne, Australia: Australian Psychological Society. pp. 143 - 148
Non-equivalence of direct and indirect measures of unrealistic optimism
Aucote, Helen and Gold, Ron. (2005). Non-equivalence of direct and indirect measures of unrealistic optimism. Psychology, Health & Medicine. 10(4), pp. 376 - 383. https://doi.org/10.1080/13548500512331315443
Lying in relationships: Protecting ourselves or protecting our partners?
Fallon, Barry John and West, Alexandra Elizabeth. (2004). Lying in relationships: Protecting ourselves or protecting our partners? In T. Bowles and Z.Pearce (Ed.). 4th Annual Conference of the APS's Psychology of Relationships Interest Group. Melbourne, Australia: Australian Psychological Society. pp. 137 - 140
Strategies for the use of deception within romantic relationships
West, Alexandra Elizabeth and Fallon, Barry John. (2004). Strategies for the use of deception within romantic relationships. In Mary Katsikitis (Ed.). 39th Australian Psychological Society Annual Conference. Melbourne, Australia: Australian Psychological Society. pp. 292 - 295
Sacred and profane: A crisis of identity for catholic priests
Fallon, Barry John and Power, Jane. (2004). Sacred and profane: A crisis of identity for catholic priests. In In D.W. Riggs and G.A. Walker (Ed.). Out in the antipodes pp. 336 - 367 Brightfire.
Is the extent of my lying and deception with the one I love related to my attachment style?
Holt, Christopher and Fallon, Barry John. (2004). Is the extent of my lying and deception with the one I love related to my attachment style? In T.Bowles and Z.Pearce (Ed.). 4th Annual Conference of the APS's Psychology of Relationships Interest Group. Melbourne, Australia: Australian Psychological Society. pp. 52 - 57
Does our attachment style change as a result of relationship experiences and contexts?
Goh, Helen and Fallon, Barry John. (2004). Does our attachment style change as a result of relationship experiences and contexts? In Mary Katsikitis (Ed.). 39th Australian Psychological Society Annual Conference 2004. Melbourne, Australia: Australian Psychological Society. pp. 99 - 103
Attraction for outgroup members: Is there a role for attitude importance and attitude similarity?
Winkelman, Cecelia, Terrett, Gillian and Fallon, Barry John. (2004). Attraction for outgroup members: Is there a role for attitude importance and attitude similarity? In T.Bowles and Z Pearce (Ed.). APS's Psychology of Relationships Intereset Group 4th Annual Conference. Melbourne, Australia: Australian Psychological Society. pp. 132 - 136
The relationship between love styles and relationship dependent and independent outcome variables: A within couple analysis
Bowles, Terence Victor and Fallon, Barry John. (2004). The relationship between love styles and relationship dependent and independent outcome variables: A within couple analysis. In T.Bowles and Z Pearce (Ed.). Australian Psychological Society's Psychology of Relationships Interest Group 4th Annual Conference. Melbourne, Australia: Australian Psychological Society. pp. 46 - 51
A longitudinal study of women directors in Australia
Fallon, Barry and Burgess, Zena. (2003). A longitudinal study of women directors in Australia. Gender in Management: An International Journal. 18(7), pp. 359 - 368.
The experience of changing and the relationship between changing and coping: An adult perspective
Fallon, Barry and Bowles, Terry. (2003). The experience of changing and the relationship between changing and coping: An adult perspective. Australian Journal of Psychology. 55(1), pp. 43 - 50. https://doi.org/10.1080/00049530412331312864
Conflict at home and work: Do we manage the conflict in the same way?
Fallon, Barry John. (2003). Conflict at home and work: Do we manage the conflict in the same way? In David Bruhn (Ed.). 2nd Hawaii International Conference on Social Science. Hawaii,United States: Hawaii International Conference on Social Sciences. pp. 1 - 23
Gender-role self-stereotyping and the relationship between equity and satisfaction in close relationships.
Fallon, Barry and Donague, N.. (2003). Gender-role self-stereotyping and the relationship between equity and satisfaction in close relationships. Sex Roles: A Journal of research. 48(June), pp. 217 - 230. https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1022869203900
Celibacy and intimacy: A clerical dilemma
Fallon, Barry John and Power, Georja. (2003). Celibacy and intimacy: A clerical dilemma. In Kathleen Moore (Ed.). 3rd Australian Psychology of Relationships Conference. Melbourne, Australia: Australian Psychological Society. pp. 79 - 84
Sacred and profane: Gay Catholic priests
Fallon, Barry John and Power, Georja. (2003). Sacred and profane: Gay Catholic priests. In Australian Psychological Society (Ed.). 38th Annual Australian Psychological Society Conference. Melbourne, Australia: Australian Psychological Society. pp. 162 - 167
Validation of the adaptive change questionnaire and definition of adaption and maladaption functioning of a clinical and non clinical group
Fallon, Barry John. (2003). Validation of the adaptive change questionnaire and definition of adaption and maladaption functioning of a clinical and non clinical group. In David Bruhn (Ed.). 2nd Hawaii International Conference on Social Sciences. Hawaii,United States: Hawaii International Conference on Social Sciences. pp. 1 - 39
The relationship between Rothwell-Miller interest categories and abilities
Fallon, Barry and Carless, Sally. (2002). The relationship between Rothwell-Miller interest categories and abilities. Australian Journal of Career Development. 11(1), pp. 27 - 31.
Are occupational gender stereotypes more or less extreme than the dominant gender in that occupation?
Fallon, Barry John, Terrett, Gillian and Winkelman, Cecelia. (2002). Are occupational gender stereotypes more or less extreme than the dominant gender in that occupation? In K. Moore (Ed.). Melbourne,Australia: Australian Psychological Society.
Priests and relationships: The case of the Catholic clergy
Fallon, Barry John and Power, Georja. (2002). Priests and relationships: The case of the Catholic clergy. In K. Moore, T. Bowles and J. Fitness et al (Ed.). Melbourne,Australia: Australian Psychological Society. pp. 49 - 58