Human dignity and consent in research biobanking

Journal article


Kirchhoffer, David and Dierickx, Kris. (2012). Human dignity and consent in research biobanking. South African Journal of Bioethics and Law. 5(2), pp. 74 - 77. https://doi.org/10.7196/SAJBL.237
AuthorsKirchhoffer, David and Dierickx, Kris
Abstract

Biobanking policy needs to take into account the concept of human dignity, because this concept is enshrined in both international and South African law. The accepted understanding of informed consent, which is also required by law, is inadequate for biobanking because it is often not possible to inform people of possible uses of their stored tissue.
If human dignity is understood as a multidimensional concept that corresponds to the multidimensionality of the human person, then human dignity can be said to be both (i) something that all people already have, as an inviolable worth that inheres in their potential to live meaningful lives; and (ii) something that people seek to realise through morally good behaviour in historically-situated relationships.
This understanding of human dignity can be used as both an interpretive lens and a normative vision. It is interpretive because it reveals how various attitudes to biobanking and the various proposed consent regimes – presumed, broad, and specific – might all be underpinned by appeals to human dignity. It is a normative vision because, given that all of these positions can be underpinned as morally meaningful with respect to human dignity, provision should be made for all of the possible consent regimes in law and in biobanking practice.
Nonetheless, where compromise cannot be avoided, then, at the very least, human dignity understood as the human potential to live a meaningful moral life must be protected.

Year2012
JournalSouth African Journal of Bioethics and Law
Journal citation5 (2), pp. 74 - 77
PublisherSouth African Medical Association
ISSN1999-7639
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)https://doi.org/10.7196/SAJBL.237
Open accessOpen access
Page range74 - 77
Research GroupSchool of Theology
Publisher's version
License
Place of publicationSouth Africa
Permalink -

https://acuresearchbank.acu.edu.au/item/871x9/human-dignity-and-consent-in-research-biobanking

Download files


Publisher's version
  • 161
    total views
  • 122
    total downloads
  • 0
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month
These values are for the period from 19th October 2020, when this repository was created.

Export as

Related outputs

Moral uncertainty and distress about voluntary assisted dying prior to legalisation and the implications for post-legalisation practice : A qualitative study of palliative and hospice care providers in Queensland, Australia
Kirchhoffer, D., Lui, C. and Ho, Anita. (2023). Moral uncertainty and distress about voluntary assisted dying prior to legalisation and the implications for post-legalisation practice : A qualitative study of palliative and hospice care providers in Queensland, Australia. BMJ Open. 13(5), pp. 1-8. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2022-065964
Dignity, conscience and religious pluralism in healthcare : An argument for a presumption in favour of respect for religious belief
Kirchhoffer, David G.. (2023). Dignity, conscience and religious pluralism in healthcare : An argument for a presumption in favour of respect for religious belief. Bioethics. 37(1), pp. 88-97. https://doi.org/10.1111/bioe.13110
Non-invasive prenatal testing : Clinical utility and ethical concerns about recent advances
Thomas, Joseph, Harraway, James and Kirchhoffer, David. (2021). Non-invasive prenatal testing : Clinical utility and ethical concerns about recent advances. Medical Journal of Australia. 214(4), pp. 168-170. https://doi.org/10.5694/mja2.50928
Public reasoning about voluntary assisted dying : An analysis of submissions to the Queensland Parliament, Australia
Kirchhoffer, David G. and Lui, Chi-Wai. (2021). Public reasoning about voluntary assisted dying : An analysis of submissions to the Queensland Parliament, Australia. Bioethics. 35(1), pp. 105-116. https://doi.org/10.1111/bioe.12777
Dignity, autonomy, and allocation of scarce medical resources during COVID-19
Kirchhoffer, David G.. (2020). Dignity, autonomy, and allocation of scarce medical resources during COVID-19. Journal of Bioethical Inquiry. 17, pp. 691-696. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11673-020-09998-3
Introduction : The limits of respect for autonomy
Kirchhoffer, David G.. (2019). Introduction : The limits of respect for autonomy. In In Kirchhoffer, David G. and Richards, Bernadette J. (Ed.). Beyond autonomy : Limits and alternatives to informed consent in research ethics and law pp. 1-14 Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108649247.001
Dignity, being and becoming in research ethics
Kirchhoffer, David G.. (2019). Dignity, being and becoming in research ethics. In In Kirchhoffer, David G. and Richards, Bernadette J. (Ed.). Beyond autonomy : Limits and alternatives to informed consent in research ethics and law pp. 117-132 Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108649247.008
Beneficence in research ethics
Kirchhoffer, David G., Favor, Christi D. and Cordner, Christopher D.. (2019). Beneficence in research ethics. In In Kirchhoffer, David G. and Richards, Bernadette J. (Ed.). Beyond autonomy : Limits and alternatives to informed consent in research ethics and law pp. 96-116 Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108649247.007
How ecology can save the life of theology: A philosophical contribution to the engagement of ecology and theology
Kirchhoffer, David. (2018). How ecology can save the life of theology: A philosophical contribution to the engagement of ecology and theology. In In C. Deane-Drummond and R. Artinian-Kaiser (Ed.). Theology and ecology across the disciplines: On care for our common home pp. 53 - 64 T&T Clark.
Human dignity and human enhancement: A multidimensional approach
Kirchhoffer, David. (2017). Human dignity and human enhancement: A multidimensional approach. Bioethics. 31(5), pp. 375 - 383. https://doi.org/10.1111/bioe.12343
Questioning human dignity: The dimensions of dignity model as a bridge between cosmopolitanism and the particular
Kirchhoffer, David. (2016). Questioning human dignity: The dimensions of dignity model as a bridge between cosmopolitanism and the particular. In In J. T. Ozolins (Ed.). Religion and Culture in Dialogue: East and West Perspectives pp. 167 - 179 Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-25724-2_11
The Roman Catholic church on the secularization of the concept of human dignity
Kirchhoffer, David. (2016). The Roman Catholic church on the secularization of the concept of human dignity. Louvain Studies. 39(3), pp. 240 - 260. https://doi.org/10.2143/LS.39.3.3170048
Personhood and human dignity
Kirchhoffer, David, Ozoliņš, Jãnis T. and Grainger, Joanne. (2015). Personhood and human dignity. In In J. T. Ozoliņš and J. Grainger (Ed.). Foundations of Healthcare Ethics: Theory to Practice pp. 51 - 69 Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9781107589834.004
Preparing for the Synod on the family: The Australian response
Kirchhoffer, David and L'Huillier, Natalie Lindner. (2014). Preparing for the Synod on the family: The Australian response. INTAMS Review: journal for the study of marriage and spirituality. 20(1), pp. 111 - 117. https://doi.org/10.2143/INT.20.1.3036703
Turtles all the way down? Pressing questions for theological anthropology in the twenty-first century
Kirchhoffer, David. (2014). Turtles all the way down? Pressing questions for theological anthropology in the twenty-first century. In In L. Boeve, Y. de Maeseneer and E. van Stichel (Ed.). Questioning the Human: Toward a Theological Anthropology for the Twenty-First Century pp. 183 - 193 Fordham University Press.
Reading the signs of the times: The challenges facing theological anthropology today
Kirchhoffer, David. (2013). Reading the signs of the times: The challenges facing theological anthropology today. In In D. G. Kirchhoffer, R. Horner and P. McCardle (Ed.). Being human: groundwork for a theological anthropology for the 21st century pp. 19 - 32 Mosaic Press.
What we have learned : Catholic social thought and the movements in Australia
Kirchhoffer, David. (2013). What we have learned : Catholic social thought and the movements in Australia. Journal of Catholic Social Thought. 10(2), pp. 401-411. https://doi.org/10.5840/jcathsoc201310223
Human dignity in contemporary ethics
Kirchhoffer, David. (2013). Human dignity in contemporary ethics Teneo Press.
Menschenwurde und biobanken
Kirchhoffer, David and Dierickx, Kris. (2013). Menschenwurde und biobanken. In In J. C. Joerden, E. Hilgendorf and F. Thiele (Ed.). Menschenwurde und Medizin: Ein interdisziplinares Handbuch pp. 935 - 948 Duncker & Humblot.
The concept of human dignity in tertiary campus ministry: More than hot air
Kirchhoffer, David. (2013). The concept of human dignity in tertiary campus ministry: More than hot air. Journal of the Tertiary Campus Ministry Association. 5(1), pp. 15 - 24.
Between revelation and reason: Human dignity in Karl Barth and Gaudium et Spes
Kirchhoffer, David. (2013). Between revelation and reason: Human dignity in Karl Barth and Gaudium et Spes. In In D. G. Kirchhoffer, R. Horner and P. McCardle (Ed.). Being human: groundwork for a theological anthropology for the 21st century pp. 69 - 84 Mosaic Press.
Human dignity and biobanks
Dierickx, Kris and Kirchhoffer, David. (2012). Human dignity and biobanks. In Annual Review of Law and Ethics pp. 247 - 258 Duncker & Humblot.
Human dignity and the moral status of animals
Kirchhoffer, David. (2012). Human dignity and the moral status of animals. Southern African Public Law. 27(1), pp. 119 - 135.
Bioethics and the demise of the concept of human dignity: Has medicine killed ethics?
Kirchhoffer, David. (2011). Bioethics and the demise of the concept of human dignity: Has medicine killed ethics? Human reproduction and genetic ethics. 17(2), pp. 141 - 154. https://doi.org/10.1558/hrge.v17i2.141
New medical technologies and the ethical challenges for minors from the perspective of human dignity
Kirchhoffer, David and Dierickx, Kris. (2011). New medical technologies and the ethical challenges for minors from the perspective of human dignity. In In J. C. Joerden, E. Hilgendorf and N. Petrillo (Ed.). Menschenw├╝rde und moderne Medizintechnik pp. 375 - 392 Nomos.
Human dignity and human tissue: A meaningful ethical relationship?
Kirchhoffer, David and Dierickx, Kris. (2011). Human dignity and human tissue: A meaningful ethical relationship? Journal of Medical Ethics. 37(9), pp. 552 - 556. https://doi.org/10.1136/jme.2010.041509
Benedict XVI, human dignity and absolute moral norms
Kirchhoffer, David. (2010). Benedict XVI, human dignity and absolute moral norms. New Blackfriars. 91(1035), pp. 586 - 608. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1741-2005.2009.01314.x
Become what you are: On the value of the concept of human dignity as an ethical criterion in light of contemporary critiques
Kirchhoffer, David. (2009). Become what you are: On the value of the concept of human dignity as an ethical criterion in light of contemporary critiques. International Journal of Philosophy and Theology. 70(1), pp. 45 - 66. https://doi.org/10.2143/BIJ.70.1.2035293
Pope Benedict XVI on the dignity of the human person: A blessing or a curse for the European project?
Kirchhoffer, David. (2007). Pope Benedict XVI on the dignity of the human person: A blessing or a curse for the European project? ET bulletin. 18(1 & 2), pp. 155 - 169.
Sacrament and being: On overcoming ontotheology in sacramental theology
Kirchhoffer, David. (2007). Sacrament and being: On overcoming ontotheology in sacramental theology. Questions Liturgiques: Studies on liturgy. 88(2), pp. 143 - 156. https://doi.org/10.2143/QL.88.2.2020848