Papias’s appeal to the ‘living and lasting voice’ over books

Book chapter


Carlson, Stephen Conrad. (2020). Papias’s appeal to the ‘living and lasting voice’ over books. In In Ayres, Lewis and Ward, H. Clifton (Ed.). The rise of the early Christian intellectual pp. 25-44 Walter de Gruyter. https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110608632-005
AuthorsCarlson, Stephen Conrad
EditorsAyres, Lewis and Ward, H. Clifton
Abstract

[Extract] If book-learning is the mark of an intellectual, then it may be unsettling to learn that the earliest commentator of the Jesus tradition in five volumes no less, Papias of Hierapolis, claimed that what comes from books is not as beneficial to him as what comes from a “living and lasting voice.” His seemingly anti-intellectual attitude has attracted considerable attention,¹ and even condemnation,² from scholars and theologians. Yet attitudes toward the written word were complex in Greco-Roman antiquity, even among the most educated. In line with scholars such as Heinrich Karpp,³ Loveday Alexander,⁴ and Jaap Mansfeld,⁵ I hold that the best way to make sense of Papias’s statement is to look at how the notion of the “living voice” functioned in antiquity. All of these scholars—and the considerable primary sources they cite—understand the “living voice” to refer to personal, oral instruction from a teacher, which was regarded as superior to mere book learning, and they hold that Papias extended the “living voice” concept to cover oral tradition. My position is somewhat more nuanced: the “living voice” in Papias retains its conventional meaning as direct, personal, oral instruction, and that it is his augmentation of the phrase with “lasting” that enables Papias to broaden its application to oral tradition, both direct and indirect, via respected teachers.

Page range25-44
Year2020
Book titleThe rise of the early Christian intellectual
PublisherWalter de Gruyter
Place of publicationBerlin, Germany
Boston, MA
SeriesArbeiten zur Kirchengeschichte ; volume 139
ISBN9783110607550
9783110608632
9783110608007
ISSN1861-5996
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110608632-005
Publisher's version
License
All rights reserved
File Access Level
Controlled
Output statusPublished
Publication dates
Online05 May 2020
Print05 May 2020
Publication process dates
Deposited16 May 2022
Permalink -

https://acuresearchbank.acu.edu.au/item/8xw7x/papias-s-appeal-to-the-living-and-lasting-voice-over-books

Restricted files

Publisher's version

  • 89
    total views
  • 0
    total downloads
  • 3
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month
These values are for the period from 19th October 2020, when this repository was created.

Export as

Related outputs

No, Galatians 4:3 τa στοιχεία τοũ κσμου does not refer to a Schmuck
Carlson, Stephen C.. (2024). No, Galatians 4:3 τa στοιχεία τοũ κσμου does not refer to a Schmuck. Zeitschrift fuer die Neutestamentliche Wissenschaft und die Kunde der Aelteren Kirche. 115(1), pp. 114-124. https://doi.org/10.1515/znw-2024-0006
Rufinus's version of Eusebius's Origen and the Politics of Martyrdom
Hanaghan, Michael and Carlson, Stephen C.. (2023). Rufinus's version of Eusebius's Origen and the Politics of Martyrdom. Journal of Early Christian Studies. 31(2), pp. 201-221. https://doi.org/10.1353/earl.2023.a899414
Papias of Hierapolis, exposition of dominical oracles : The fragments, testimonia, and reception of a second-century commentator
Carlson, Stephen C.. (2021). Papias of Hierapolis, exposition of dominical oracles : The fragments, testimonia, and reception of a second-century commentator Oxford University Press.
Rufinus’s Origenization of Eusebius in his translation of the Historia Ecclesiastica
Carlson, Stephen C.. (2021). Rufinus’s Origenization of Eusebius in his translation of the Historia Ecclesiastica. In In Fürst, Alfons (Ed.). Perspectives on Origen and the history of his reception pp. 151-160 Aschendorff Verlag.
The reception of the Watchers in Tertullian with regard to 1 Cor. 11.2-16
Carlson, Stephen C.. (2021). The reception of the Watchers in Tertullian with regard to 1 Cor. 11.2-16. In In Barclay, John M. G. and Crabbe, Kylie (Ed.). The reception of Jewish tradition in the social imagination of the early Christians pp. 47-60 T&T Clark. https://doi.org/10.5040/9780567696014.ch-003
Fragments of Papias
Carlson, Stephen C.. (2021). Fragments of Papias. In In Bird, Michael F. and Harrower, Scott D. (Ed.). The Cambridge companion to the Apostolic Fathers pp. 332-350 Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108554992.018
A bias at the heart of the coherence-based genealogical method (CBGM)
Carlson, Stephen C.. (2020). A bias at the heart of the coherence-based genealogical method (CBGM). Journal of Biblical Literature. 139(2), pp. 319-340. https://doi.org/10.15699/JBL.1392.2020.5
‘The Jenny and the Colt’ in Matthew’s messianic entry, Part 1: Matthew 21:5 as a reading of Zechariah 9:9 in Light of Mark 11:1-10
Carlson, Stephen C.. (2019). ‘The Jenny and the Colt’ in Matthew’s messianic entry, Part 1: Matthew 21:5 as a reading of Zechariah 9:9 in Light of Mark 11:1-10. Catholic Biblical Quarterly. 81(1), pp. 62 - 84. https://doi.org/10.1353/cbq.2019.0051
Origen's use of papias
Carlson, Stephen. (2019). Origen's use of papias. In B. Bitton-Ashkelony, O. Irshai and A. Kofsky, H. Newman and L. Perrone (Ed.). 12th International Origen Congress, Jerusalem, 25-29 June 2017. Leuven, Belgium: Peeters. pp. 535 - 545
‘The Jenny and the Colt’ in Matthew’s messianic entry, Part 2: Matthew 21:7 as a reading of Mark 11:7 in Light of Zechariah 9:9
Carlson, Stephen C.. (2019). ‘The Jenny and the Colt’ in Matthew’s messianic entry, Part 2: Matthew 21:7 as a reading of Mark 11:7 in Light of Zechariah 9:9. Catholic Biblical Quarterly. 81(2), pp. 235 - 251. https://doi.org/10.1353/cbq.2019.0105
'Lasst uns zur freundlichkeit gehen': A saying misattributed to Papias of Hierapolis
Carlson, Stephen. (2018). 'Lasst uns zur freundlichkeit gehen': A saying misattributed to Papias of Hierapolis. Journal of Theological Studies. 69(2), pp. 573 - 576. https://doi.org/10.1093/jts/fly119
Eschatological Viticulture in 1 Enoch, 2 Baruch, and the Presbyters of Papias
Carlson, Stephen. (2017). Eschatological Viticulture in 1 Enoch, 2 Baruch, and the Presbyters of Papias. Vigiliae Christinane. 71(1), pp. 37 - 58. https://doi.org/10.1163/15700720-12341289
The polysemy of πάλιν with particular attention to Mark 15,13 (and John 18,40)
Carlson, Stephen. (2017). The polysemy of πάλιν with particular attention to Mark 15,13 (and John 18,40). Ephemerides Theologicae Lovanienses. 93(1), pp. 51 - 74. https://doi.org/10.2143/ETL.93.1.3203591
On Paul's second visit to Corinth: 'The Greek passage', parsing, and presupposition in 2 Corinthians 2:1
Carlson, Stephen C.. (2016). On Paul's second visit to Corinth: 'The Greek passage', parsing, and presupposition in 2 Corinthians 2:1. Journal of Biblical Literature. 135(3), pp. 597 - 615. https://doi.org/10.15699/jbl.1353.2016.3123
The Text of Galatians and its History
Carlson, Stephen C.. (2015). The Text of Galatians and its History Mohr Siebeck.
Problems with the Non-Aversion Principle for Reconstructing Q
Carlson, Stephen. (2015). Problems with the Non-Aversion Principle for Reconstructing Q. In In J C Poirer and J Peterson (Ed.). Marcan Priority Without Q: Explorations in the Farrer Hypothesis pp. 44 - 61 Bloomsbury T & T Clark. https://doi.org/10.5040/9781472550644
Review of Nicholas P. Lunn, The Original Ending of Mark
Carlson, Stephen. (2015). Review of Nicholas P. Lunn, The Original Ending of Mark. Australian Biblical Review. 63, pp. 96 - 97.
"For Sinai is a mountain in Arabia": A note on the text of Galatians 4,25
Carlson, Stephen C.. (2014). "For Sinai is a mountain in Arabia": A note on the text of Galatians 4,25. Zeitschrift fur die Neutestamentliche Wissenschaft und die Kunde der Alteren Kirche. 105(1), pp. 80 - 101. https://doi.org/10.1515/znw-2014-0005
Origen's use of the Gospel of Thomas
Carlson, Stephen C.. (2014). Origen's use of the Gospel of Thomas. In In J. H. Charlesworth, L. M. McDonald and B. A. Jurgens (Ed.). Sacra Scriptura: How 'Non-Canonical' Texts Functioned in Early Judaism and Early Christianity pp. 137 - 151 Bloomsbury T & T Clark.
The Davidic Key for Counting the Generations in Matthew 1 : 17
Carlson, Stephen C.. (2014). The Davidic Key for Counting the Generations in Matthew 1 : 17. Catholic Biblical Quarterly. 76(4), pp. 665 - 683.
Can the academy protect itself from one of its own? The case of secret Mark
Carlson, Stephen C.. (2013). Can the academy protect itself from one of its own? The case of secret Mark. In In T. Burke (Ed.). Ancient gospel or modern forgery? The Secret Gospel of Mark in debate pp. 299 - 307 Cascade Books.
The accommodations of Joseph and Mary in Bethlehem: Κατάλυμα in Luke 2.7
Carlson, Stephen C.. (2010). The accommodations of Joseph and Mary in Bethlehem: Κατάλυμα in Luke 2.7. New Testament Studies. 56(3), pp. 326 - 342. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0028688509990282