Seeing things differently: Recognition, ethics, praxis

Journal article


Doecke, Brenton, Kostogriz, Alex and Illesca, Bella. (2010) Seeing things differently: Recognition, ethics, praxis. English Teaching: Practice and Critique. 9(2), pp. 81 - 98.
AuthorsDoecke, Brenton, Kostogriz, Alex and Illesca, Bella
Abstract

This essay focuses on the recent introduction by the Australian Federal Government of standardised literacy testing in all states across Australia (that is, the National Assessment Program – Literacy and Numeracy, or NAPLAN), and explores the way this reform is mediating the work of English literacy educators in primary and secondary schools. We draw on data collected as part of a research project funded by the Australian Research Council, involving interviews with teachers about their experiences of implementing standardised testing. These interviews indicate that the introduction of standardised testing does not merely constitute an additional part of teachers” workloads, but that it is having a significant impact on their identity as language educators, their understanding of curriculum and pedagogy, and the relationships they seek to maintain with their students. By introducing the NAPLAN tests, the Australian Federal Government is going down the path of other neo-liberal governments around the world. No doubt the story we tell will be familiar to readers in other countries. Our aim, however, is more than simply to give yet another account of the tensions experienced by committed language and literacy teachers as they implement neoliberal policy mandates. Key questions for us include: Why is the Australian government persisting with such policies, even when they have had such dubious consequences (teaching to the test, dumbing down, and so on.) in other national settings? How might educators resist these reforms? What intellectual resources might enable us to articulate an alternative vision of language education to that imposed by neoliberal reforms?

We present an account of conversations with a group of teachers in a primary school in the northern suburbs of Melbourne, not in order to make large claims about how the profession in Australia as a whole judges standardsbased reforms, but because their talk prompts reflection about the possibility of resisting such policy initiatives. Our impulse is largely a philosophical one – we are raising questions about how neoliberal reforms construct teachers and their students, what they presuppose about the nature of life and its potential, and how educators might dissent from the world view that is being imposed. And rather than simply investigating how teachers are grappling with standards-based reforms, as though it is yet again a matter of putting teachers under the spotlight, we also raise questions about the responsibility of academics and teacher educators to maintain a critical standpoint within the policy environment created by such changes.

KeywordsLanguage and literacy education; standards-based reforms; cultural diversity; ethics and politics
Year2010
JournalEnglish Teaching: Practice and Critique
Journal citation9 (2), pp. 81 - 98
PublisherUniversity of Waikato
ISSN1175-8708
Scopus EID2-s2.0-78650799894
Page range81 - 98
Research GroupSchool of Education
Publisher's version
File Access Level
Controlled
Place of publicationNew Zealand
Permalink -

https://acuresearchbank.acu.edu.au/item/8684x/seeing-things-differently-recognition-ethics-praxis

Restricted files

Publisher's version

  • 2
    total views
  • 0
    total downloads
  • 0
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month
These values are for the period from 19th October 2020, when this repository was created.

Export as

Related outputs

Teacher education policy and practice: Evidence of impact, impact of evidence
Nuttall, Joce, Kostogriz, Alexander, Jones, Mellita M. and Martin, Jenny. In J. Nuttall, A. Kostogriz and M. Jones and J. Martin (Ed.). (2017) Teacher education policy and practice: Evidence of impact, impact of evidence Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-10-4133-4
Advancing partnership research: A spatial analysis of a jointly planned teacher education partnership
Ryan, Josephine Mary, Butler, Helen, Kostogriz, Alexander and Nailer, Sarah. (2016) Advancing partnership research: A spatial analysis of a jointly planned teacher education partnership. In In R. Brandenburg, S. McDonough and J. Burke & S. White (Ed.). Teacher education: Innovation, intervention and impact pp. 175 - 191 Springer Science and Business Media. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-10-0785-9_11
An everyday life perspective on the institutional and cultural identities of Chinese students in Australia
Ai, Bin and Kostogriz, Alexander. (2015) An everyday life perspective on the institutional and cultural identities of Chinese students in Australia. In In A. Ata and A. Kostogriz (Ed.). pp. 13 - 27 Australian Academic Press.
Towards a pedagogy of experiential thirding in language education
Welsh, Alistair and Kostogriz, Alexander. (2015) Towards a pedagogy of experiential thirding in language education. In In A. Ata and A. Kostogriz (Ed.). pp. 105 - 120 Australian Academic Press.
Investigating the effectiveness of teacher education for early career teachers in diverse settings : The longitudinal research we have to have
Rowan, Leonie, Mayer, Diane, Kline, Jodie, Kostogriz, Alexander and Walker-Gibbs, Bernadette. (2015) Investigating the effectiveness of teacher education for early career teachers in diverse settings : The longitudinal research we have to have. The Australian Educational Researcher (print). 42(3), pp. 273 - 298. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13384-014-0163-y
Professional standards and ethics in teaching Asia literacy
Kostogriz, Alexander. (2015) Professional standards and ethics in teaching Asia literacy. In In C. Halse (Ed.). Asia literate schooling in the Asian century pp. 103 - 116 Routledge.
Multiculturalism, schooling and Muslims in Australia: From orientation to a possibility of hospitable education
Preger, Margaret and Kostogriz, Alexander. (2014) Multiculturalism, schooling and Muslims in Australia: From orientation to a possibility of hospitable education. In In A. A. Ata (Ed.). Education integration challenges: The case of Muslims in Australia pp. 157 - 166 David Lovell Publishing.
The ethical practice of teaching literacy: Accountability or responsibility?
Kostogriz, Alexander and Doecke, Brenton. (2013) The ethical practice of teaching literacy: Accountability or responsibility? Australian Journal of Language and Literacy. 36(2), pp. 90 - 98.
Accountability and the affective labour of teachers: A Marxist-Vygotskian perspective
Kostogriz, Alexander. (2012) Accountability and the affective labour of teachers: A Marxist-Vygotskian perspective. The Australian Educational Researcher. 39(4), pp. 397 - 412. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13384-012-0072-x
Interrogating the ethics of literacy intervention in Indigenous schools
Kostogriz, Alexander. (2011) Interrogating the ethics of literacy intervention in Indigenous schools. English Teaching: Practice and Critique. 10(2), pp. 24 - 38.
The future of diversity and difference: Can the national curriculum for English be hospitable?
Kostogriz, Alexander. (2011) The future of diversity and difference: Can the national curriculum for English be hospitable? In In B. Doecke, G. Parr and W. Sawyer (Ed.). Creating an Australian curriculum for English: National agendas, local contexts pp. 201 - 214 Phoenix Education.
Standards-based accountability: Refication, responsibility and the ethical subject
Kostogriz, Alexander and Doecke, Brenton. (2011) Standards-based accountability: Refication, responsibility and the ethical subject. Teaching Education. 22(4), pp. 397 - 412. https://doi.org/10.1080/10476210.2011.587870