Reading first Thessalonians as a consolatory letter in light of Seneca and ancient handbooks on letter-writing

Journal article


Neil, Bronwen 2016. Reading first Thessalonians as a consolatory letter in light of Seneca and ancient handbooks on letter-writing. New Testament Studies. 62 (1), pp. 31 - 48. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0028688515000351
AuthorsNeil, Bronwen
Abstract

In his first letter to the Thessalonians, Paul addressed the occasion of deaths among Christians with stock arguments of the consolatory genre, without using the typical epistolary structure associated with consolation in ancient handbooks of letter-writing. It is demonstrated that three of Seneca the Younger's letters also employed stock arguments of consolation, but did not follow the usual structure for a letter of consolation. Using Seneca's letters as a test case for what constituted pagan ideas of consolation, we highlight some compelling reasons for reading First Thessalonians as a letter of consolation, a reading that offers some new insights into the passage on the right Christian attitude towards death in 1 Thess 4.13–5.11.

Keywordsconsolation; eschatology; New Testament; Seneca; Paul;  Thessalonians; letters; epistolary handbooks
Year2016
JournalNew Testament Studies
Journal citation62 (1), pp. 31 - 48
PublisherCambridge University Press
ISSN0028-6885
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)https://doi.org/10.1017/S0028688515000351
Scopus EID2-s2.0-84950296069
Page range31 - 48
Research GroupCentre for Biblical and Early Christian Studies
Place of publicationUnited Kingdom
Permalink -

https://acuresearchbank.acu.edu.au/item/86z3z/reading-first-thessalonians-as-a-consolatory-letter-in-light-of-seneca-and-ancient-handbooks-on-letter-writing

Restricted files

Publisher's version

  • 1
    total views
  • 0
    total downloads
  • 1
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

Studying dream interpretation from early Christianity to the rise of Islam
Neil, Bronwen Jennifer 2016. Studying dream interpretation from early Christianity to the rise of Islam. Journal of Religious History. 40 (1), pp. 44 - 64. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-9809.12262
Theophanes Confessor on the Arab Conquest: The Latin Version of Anastasius Bibliothecarius
Neil, Bronwen 2016. Theophanes Confessor on the Arab Conquest: The Latin Version of Anastasius Bibliothecarius. Centre de Recherche d'Histoire et Civilisation de Byzance: Travaux et Memoires. 19, pp. 149 - 157.
De Profundis: The Letters and Archives of Pelagius I of Rome (556-561)
Neil, Bronwen 2015. De Profundis: The Letters and Archives of Pelagius I of Rome (556-561). in: P. Allen and B. Neil (ed.) Collecting Early Christian Letters: From the Apostle Paul to Late Antiquity United Kingdom: Cambridge University Press. pp. 206 - 220
The Oxford handbook of Maximus the Confessor
Allen, Pauline and Neil, Bronwen 2015. The Oxford handbook of Maximus the Confessor. Oxford, United Kingdom: Oxford University Press.
Dream Interpretation and Christian Identity in Late Antique Rome and Byzantium
Neil, Bronwen 2015. Dream Interpretation and Christian Identity in Late Antique Rome and Byzantium. in: G.D. Dunn and W. Mayer (ed.) Christians Shaping Identity from the Roman Empire to Bysantium: Studies Inspired by Pauline Allen Netherlands: Brill. pp. 321 - 341
Collecting early Christian Letters: From the Apostle Paul to Late Antiquity
Neil, Bronwen and Allen, Pauline 2015. Collecting early Christian Letters: From the Apostle Paul to Late Antiquity. Cambridge, United Kingdom: Cambridge University Press.
Continuities and changes in the practice of letter-collecting from Cicero to Late Antiquity
Neil, Bronwen 2015. Continuities and changes in the practice of letter-collecting from Cicero to Late Antiquity. in: P. Allen and B. Neil (ed.) Collecting Early Christian Letters: From the Apostle Paul to Late Antiquity United Kingdom: Cambridge University Press. pp. 3 - 17
Divine Providence and the Gnomic Will Before Maximus
Neil, Bronwen 2015. Divine Providence and the Gnomic Will Before Maximus. in: Pauline Allen and Bronwen Neil (ed.) The Oxford Handbook of Maximus the Confessor Oxford: Oxford University Press. pp. 235 - 249
Crisis in the Letters of Gelasius I (492-496): A New Model of Crisis Management?
Neil, Bronwen 2015. Crisis in the Letters of Gelasius I (492-496): A New Model of Crisis Management? in: G.D. Dunn (ed.) The Bishop of Rome in Late Antiquity United Kingdom: Ashgate Publishing Limited. pp. 155 - 174
The Letters of Gelasius I (492-496): Pastor and micro-manager of the Church of Rome
Neil, Bronwen and Allen, Pauline 2014. The Letters of Gelasius I (492-496): Pastor and micro-manager of the Church of Rome. Turnhout, Belgium: Brepols.
Crisis Management in Late Antiquity (410-590 CE): A Survey of the Evidence from Episcopal Letters
Allen, Pauline and Neil, Bronwen 2013. Crisis Management in Late Antiquity (410-590 CE): A Survey of the Evidence from Episcopal Letters. Belgium: E.J. Brill Academic Publishers.
The Decretals of Gelasius 1: Making Canon Law in Late Antiquity
Neil, Bronwen 2013. The Decretals of Gelasius 1: Making Canon Law in Late Antiquity. V. Grossi (ed.) XL Incontro di Studiosi del-Antichità Cristiana (Roma, 10-12 maggio 2012). Italy: Institutum Patristicum Augustinianum. pp. 657 - 667
A crisis of orthodoxy: Leo I's fight against the 'Deadly Disease' of Heresy
Neil, Bronwen 2012. A crisis of orthodoxy: Leo I's fight against the 'Deadly Disease' of Heresy. in: DC Sim and P Allen (ed.) United Kingdom: T&T Clark International. pp. 144 - 158
Divine providence and free will in Gregory of Nyssa and his theological milieu
Neil, Bronwen 2012. Divine providence and free will in Gregory of Nyssa and his theological milieu. Phronema. 27 (2), pp. 35 - 51.
A crisis of orthodoxy: Leo I's fight against the 'Deadly Disease' of Heresy
Neil, Bronwen 2012. A crisis of orthodoxy: Leo I's fight against the 'Deadly Disease' of Heresy. in: D Sim and P Allen (ed.) United Kingdom: T&T Clark International. pp. 144 - 159
Crisis and wealth in Byzantine Italy: the Libri Pontificales of Rome and Ravenna
Neil, Bronwen 2012. Crisis and wealth in Byzantine Italy: the Libri Pontificales of Rome and Ravenna. Byzantion: revue internationale des etudes byzantines. 82, pp. 279 - 303.
Pagan ritual and Christian liturgy: Leo the Great's preaching on sun-worship
Neil, Bronwen 2011. Pagan ritual and Christian liturgy: Leo the Great's preaching on sun-worship. in: W. Kinzig, U. Volp and J. Schmidt (ed.) Liturgie und Ritual in der Alten Kirche Belgium: Peeters Publishing. pp. 127 - 140
Displaced peoples: Reflections from Late Antiquity on a contemporary crisis
Neil, Bronwen and Allen, Pauline 2011. Displaced peoples: Reflections from Late Antiquity on a contemporary crisis. Pacifica: Australasian theological studies (print version). 24 (1), pp. 29 - 42. https://doi.org/10.1177/1030570X1102400103
Discourses on the Poor in the Psalms : Augustine's Enarrationes in Psalmos
Allen, Pauline and Neil, Bronwen J. 2011. Discourses on the Poor in the Psalms : Augustine's Enarrationes in Psalmos. in: A Andreopoulos, A Casiday and C Harrison (ed.) Meditations of the Heart: The Psalms in Early Christian Thought and Practice Belgium: Brepols. pp. 181 - 204
Imperial Benefactions to the Fifth-century Roman Church
Neil, Bronwen J. 2011. Imperial Benefactions to the Fifth-century Roman Church. in: G Nathan and L Garland (ed.) Basileia: Essays on Imperium and Culture in Honour of E.M. and M.J. Jeffreys Australia: Australian Association for Byzantine Studies. pp. 55 - 66
From Tristia to Gaudia : The exile and martyrdom of Pope Martin I
Neil, Bronwen 2010. From Tristia to Gaudia : The exile and martyrdom of Pope Martin I. in: J. Leemans (ed.) Martyrdom and Persecution in Late Antique Christianity: Festschrift in honour of Boudewijn Dehandschutter Belgium: Peeters Publishing. pp. 179 - 194
Blessed are the rich: Leo the Great and the Roman poor
Neil, Bronwen 2010. Blessed are the rich: Leo the Great and the Roman poor. J Baun, A Cameron and M Edwards &M Vinzent (ed.) Belgium: Peeters Publishing.
Crisis management in late antiquity: The evidence of Episcopal Letters
Allen, Pauline and Neil, Bronwen 2010. Crisis management in late antiquity: The evidence of Episcopal Letters.
Models of gift-giving in the preaching of Leo the Great
Neil, Bronwen 2010. Models of gift-giving in the preaching of Leo the Great. Journal of Early Christian Studies. 18 (2), pp. 225 - 259. https://doi.org/10.1353/earl.0.0322
Spiritual peace and civic harmony in Leo the Great's Sermo 95
Neil, Bronwen 2010. Spiritual peace and civic harmony in Leo the Great's Sermo 95. in: David Luckensmeyer and Pauline Allen (ed.) Studies of Religion and Politics in the Early Christian Centuries Australia: St Pauls Publications. pp. 263 - 286
Preaching poverty in late antiquity: Perceptions and realities
Allen, Pauline, Neil, Bronwen Jennifer and Mayer, Wendy Elizabeth 2009. Preaching poverty in late antiquity: Perceptions and realities. Germany: Evangelische Verlagsanstalt.
Anastasius bibliothecarius
Neil, Bronwen Jennifer 2009. Anastasius bibliothecarius. in: D. Thomas, B Roggema and J. Sala et al. (ed.) Christian-Muslim relations: a bibliographical history E.J. Brill Academic Publishers. pp. 786 - 790
Leo the Great
Neil, Bronwen 2009. Leo the Great. United Kingdom: Routledge.
The politics of hagiography in ninth-century Rome
Neil, Bronwen Jennifer 2007. The politics of hagiography in ninth-century Rome. in: C. Bishop (ed.) Text and Transmission in Medieval Europe Cambridge Scholars Publishing. pp. 58 - 75
Blessed is poverty: Leo the great on almsgiving
Neil, Bronwen 2007. Blessed is poverty: Leo the great on almsgiving. Sacris Erudiri: A Journal on the Inheritance of Early and Medieval Christianity. 46, pp. 143 - 156. https://doi.org/10.1484/J.SE.1.100097
Towards defining a Christian culture: The Christian transformation of classical literature
Neil, Bronwen 2007. Towards defining a Christian culture: The Christian transformation of classical literature. in: A. Casiday and F. Norris (ed.) The Cambridge History of Christianity; volume 2 Cambridge, United Kingdom: Cambridge University Press. pp. 317 - 342
Exploring the limits of literal exegesis: Augustine's reading of gen 1:26
Neil, Bronwen 2006. Exploring the limits of literal exegesis: Augustine's reading of gen 1:26. Pacifica: Australasian theological studies. 19, pp. 144 - 155.
The miracles of Saints Cyrus and John: The Greek text and its transmission
Neil, Bronwen 2006. The miracles of Saints Cyrus and John: The Greek text and its transmission. Journal of the Australian Early Medieval Association. 2, pp. 183 - 193.
On true humility: An anonymous letter on poverty and the female ascetic
Neil, Bronwen Jennifer 2006. On true humility: An anonymous letter on poverty and the female ascetic. in: W. Mayer, P. Allen and L. Cross (ed.) Prayer and Spirituality in the Early Church IV: The Spiritual Life St Pauls Publications. pp. 233 - 246
Narrating the Trials and Deaths of Martin I and Maximus the Confessor
Neil, Bronwen Jennifer 2006. Narrating the Trials and Deaths of Martin I and Maximus the Confessor. J. Burke (ed.) Byzantine Narrative: Papers in Honour of Roger Scott. Canberra, Australia: Australian Association for Byzantine Studies. pp. 71 - 83
Letter of Vigilius to John
Neil, Bronwen Jennifer 2006. Letter of Vigilius to John. in: J. Behr (ed.) John Chrysostom. The Cult of the Saints St Vladmir's Seminary Press. pp. 265 - 280
Commemorating Pope Martin 1 :his trial in Constantinople
Neil, Bronwen Jennifer 2006. Commemorating Pope Martin 1 :his trial in Constantinople. Studia Patristica 39. Leuven, Belgium: Peeters Publishing.
Seventh-century popes and martyrs: The political hagiography of Anastasius Bibliothecarius
Neil, Bronwen Jennifer 2006. Seventh-century popes and martyrs: The political hagiography of Anastasius Bibliothecarius. Brepols: Turnhout.
"The blessed passion of holy love": Maximus the confessor's spiritual psychology
Neil, Bronwen 2004. "The blessed passion of holy love": Maximus the confessor's spiritual psychology. Australian Ejournal of Theology. February (2), pp. 1 - 8.
It is I who am a man; you who are women: Sayings of the desert mothers
Neil, Bronwen 2004. It is I who am a man; you who are women: Sayings of the desert mothers. Women-Church. 35 (Spring), pp. 11 - 15.
The introduction of old church Slavonic to the first Bulgarian empire: The role of St. Cyril and Methodius
Neil, Bronwen Jennifer 2004. The introduction of old church Slavonic to the first Bulgarian empire: The role of St. Cyril and Methodius. in: B. Janssens, B. Roosen and P. Van Deun (ed.) Orientalia Lovaniensia Analecta Peeters Publishing. pp. 455 - 474
The life of Maximus the Confessor: Recension 3
Allen, Pauline and Neil, Bronwen Jennifer 2003. The life of Maximus the Confessor: Recension 3. Australia: St Pauls Publications.
Two views of vice and virtue: Augustine of Hippo and Maximus the Confessor
Neil, Bronwen Jennifer 2003. Two views of vice and virtue: Augustine of Hippo and Maximus the Confessor. in: B. Neil, G. Dunn and L. Cross (ed.) Prayer and Spirituality in the Early Church III: Liturgy and Life St Pauls Publications. pp. 261 - 271
The cult of Pope Clement in ninth-century Rome
Neil, Bronwen 2003. The cult of Pope Clement in ninth-century Rome. Ephemerides Liturgicae: commentarium trimestre de re liturgica. 117, pp. 103 - 113.
Rufinus' translation of the epistola clementis ad iacobum
Neil, Bronwen 2003. Rufinus' translation of the epistola clementis ad iacobum. Augustinianum. 43, pp. 25 - 39.
Maximus the Confessor and his companions: Documents from exile
Allen, Pauline and Neil, Bronwen Jennifer 2002. Maximus the Confessor and his companions: Documents from exile. United Kingdom: Oxford University Press.
A critical edition of Anastasius Bibliothecarius' Latin Translation of Greek Documents Pertaining to the Life of Maximus the Confessor, with an analysis of Anastasius' translation methodology, and an english translation of the latin text
Neil, Bronwen 1998. A critical edition of Anastasius Bibliothecarius' Latin Translation of Greek Documents Pertaining to the Life of Maximus the Confessor, with an analysis of Anastasius' translation methodology, and an english translation of the latin text. Thesis https://doi.org/10.4226/66/5a8e26b4d84e5