A meta-analysis comparing the effectiveness of alternate day fasting, the 5:2 diet, and time-restricted eating for weight loss

Journal article

Elortegui Pascual, Paloma, Rolands, Maryann R., Eldridge, Alison L., Kassis, Amira, Mainardi, Fabio, Lê, Kim-Anne, Karagounis, Leonidas G., Gut, Philipp and Varady, Krista A.. (2023). A meta-analysis comparing the effectiveness of alternate day fasting, the 5:2 diet, and time-restricted eating for weight loss. Obesity. 31(Supp. 1), pp. 9-21. https://doi.org/10.1002/oby.23568
AuthorsElortegui Pascual, Paloma, Rolands, Maryann R., Eldridge, Alison L., Kassis, Amira, Mainardi, Fabio, Lê, Kim-Anne, Karagounis, Leonidas G., Gut, Philipp and Varady, Krista A.
Abstract

Objective
The objective of this meta-analysis was to compare the effectiveness of different intermittent fasting (IF) regimens on weight loss, in the general population, and compare these to traditional caloric energy restriction (CER).

Methods
Three databases were searched from 2011 to June 2021 for randomized controlled trials (RCTs) that assessed weight loss and IF, including alternate day fasting (ADF), the 5:2 diet, and time-restricted eating (TRE). A random effect network analysis was used to compare the effectiveness between the three regimens. Meta-regression analysis was presented as weighted mean differences of body weight loss.

Results
The exploratory random effects network analysis of 24 RCTs (n = 1768) ranked ADF as the most effective, followed by CER and TRE. The meta-analysis showed that IF regimens resulted in similar weight loss to CER (mean difference 0.26 kg, 95% CI: –0.31 to 0.84; p = 0.37). Compliance was generally high (>80%) in trials shorter than 3 months.

Conclusions
The present meta-analysis concludes that IF is comparable to CER and a promising alternative for weight loss. Among the three regimens, ADF showed the highest effectiveness for weight loss, followed by CER and TRE. Further well-powered RCTs with longer durations of intervention are required to draw solid conclusions.

Year2023
JournalObesity
Journal citation31 (Supp. 1), pp. 9-21
PublisherWiley Periodicals LLC
ISSN1930-7381
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)https://doi.org/10.1002/oby.23568
PubMed ID36349432
Scopus EID2-s2.0-85141564376
PubMed Central IDPMC10098946
Open accessPublished as ‘gold’ (paid) open access
Page range9-21
FunderSociété des Produits Nestlé SA
Nestlé Health Sciences, Lausanne, Switzerland
Publisher's version
License
File Access Level
Open
Output statusPublished
Publication dates
Online08 Nov 2022
Publication process dates
Accepted11 Jul 2022
Deposited29 Nov 2023
Permalink -

https://acuresearchbank.acu.edu.au/item/8zzz6/a-meta-analysis-comparing-the-effectiveness-of-alternate-day-fasting-the-5-2-diet-and-time-restricted-eating-for-weight-loss

Log in to edit

Download files

Publisher's version
OA_Elortegui_2023_A_meta_analysis_comparing_the_effectiveness.pdf
License: CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
File access level: Open

  • 71
    total views
  • 27
    total downloads
  • 5
    views this month
  • 1
    downloads this month
These values are for the period from 19th October 2020, when this repository was created.

Export as

Related outputs

Skeletal muscle myostatin mRNA expression is upregulated in aged human adults with excess adiposity but is not associated with insulin resistance and ageing
Wilhelmsen, Andrew, Stephens, F, Bennett, Andrew J., Karagounis, Leonidas, Jones, Simon W. and Tsintzas, Kostas. (2023). Skeletal muscle myostatin mRNA expression is upregulated in aged human adults with excess adiposity but is not associated with insulin resistance and ageing. GeroScience. 46(2), pp. 2033-2049. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11357-023-00956-6
A randomized controlled clinical trial in healthy older adults to determine efficacy of glycine and n-acetylcysteine supplementation on glutathione redox status and oxidative damage
Lizzo, Giulia, Migliavacca, Eugenia, Lamers, Daniela, Frézal, Adrien, Corthesy, John, Vinyes-Parès, Gerard, Bosco, Nabil, Karagounis, Leonidas, Hövelmann, Ulrike, Heise, Tim, Von Eynatten, Maximilian and Gut, Philipp. (2022). A randomized controlled clinical trial in healthy older adults to determine efficacy of glycine and n-acetylcysteine supplementation on glutathione redox status and oxidative damage. Frontiers in Aging. 3, p. Article 852569. https://doi.org/10.3389/fragi.2022.852569
Impact of moderate dietary protein restriction on glucose homeostasis in a model of estrogen deficiency
Fournier, Carole, Karagounis, Leonidas G., Sacco, Sandra M., Horcajada, Marie-Noelle, Decaens, Thomas, Offord, Elizabeth A., Bouzakri, Karim and Ammann, Patrick. (2022). Impact of moderate dietary protein restriction on glucose homeostasis in a model of estrogen deficiency. Journal of Nutritional Biochemistry. 102, p. Article 108952. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jnutbio.2022.108952
A randomized controlled trial to isolate the effects of fasting and energy restriction on weight loss and metabolic health in lean adults
Templeman, Iain, Smith, Harry Alex, Chowdhury, Enhad, Chen, Yung-Chih, Carroll, Harriet, Johnson-Bonson, Drusus, Hengist, Aaron, Smith, Rowan, Creighton, Jade, Clayton, David, Varley, Ian, Karagounis, Leonidas Georgios, Wilhelmsen, Andrew, Tsintzas, Kostas, Reeves, Sue, Walhin, Jean-Philippe, Gonzalez, Javier T., Thompson, Dylan and Betts, James A.. (2021). A randomized controlled trial to isolate the effects of fasting and energy restriction on weight loss and metabolic health in lean adults. Science Translational Medicine. 13(598), pp. 1-12. https://doi.org/10.1126/scitranslmed.abd8034
Low-grade systemic inflammation interferes with anabolic and catabolic characteristics of the aged human skeletal muscle
Draganidis, Dimitrios, Jamurtas, Athanasios Z., Chondrogianni, Niki, Mastorakos, Georgios, Jung, Tobias, Grune, Tilman, Papadopoulos, Constantinos, Papanikolaou, Konstantinos, Papassotiriou, Ioannis, Papaevgeniou, Nikoletta, Poulios, Athanasios, Batrakoulis, Alexios, Deli, Chariklia K., Georgakouli, Kalliopi, Chatzinikolaou, Athanasios, Karagounis, Leonidas G. and Fatouros, Ioannis G.. (2021). Low-grade systemic inflammation interferes with anabolic and catabolic characteristics of the aged human skeletal muscle. Oxidative Medicine and Cellular Longevity. 2021, p. Article 8376915. https://doi.org/10.1155/2021/8376915
Unacylated ghrelin, leptin, and appetite display diurnal rhythmicity in lean Adults
Templeman, Iain, Smith, Harry A., Walhin, Jean-Philippe, Middleton, Benita, Gonzalez, Javier T., Karagounis, Leonidas G., Johnston, Jonathan D. and Betts, James A.. (2021). Unacylated ghrelin, leptin, and appetite display diurnal rhythmicity in lean Adults. Journal of Applied Physiology. 130(5), pp. 1534-1543. https://doi.org/10.1152/japplphysiol.00920.2020
Systemic and metabolic signature of sarcopenia in community-dwelling older adults
Lu, Yanxia, Karagounis, Leonidas G., Ng, Tze Pin, Carre, Christophe, Narang, Vipin, Wong, Glenn, Tan, Crystal Tze Ying, Nyunt, Ma Shwe Zin, Gao, Qi, Abel, Brian, Poidinger, Michael, Fulop, Tamas, Bosco, Nabil and Larbi, Anis. (2020). Systemic and metabolic signature of sarcopenia in community-dwelling older adults. Journals of Gerontology: Series A Biological Sciences and Medical Sciences. 75(2), pp. 309-317. https://doi.org/10.1093/gerona/glz001
Chronotype : Implications for Epidemiologic Studies on Chrono-Nutrition and Cardiometabolic Health
Almoosawi, Suzana, Vingeliene, Snieguole, Gachon, Frédéric, Voortman, Trudy, Palla, Luigi, Johnston, Jonathan D., Van Dam, Rob, Darimont, Christian and Karagounis, Leonidas. (2019). Chronotype : Implications for Epidemiologic Studies on Chrono-Nutrition and Cardiometabolic Health. Advances in Nutrition. 10(1), pp. 30-42. https://doi.org/10.1093/advances/nmy070
Ingestion of a pre-bedtime protein containing beverage prevents overnight induced negative whole body protein balance in healthy middle-aged men : A randomized trial
Karagounis, Leonidas G., Beaumont, Maurice, Donato-Capel, Laurence, Godin, Jean-Philippe, Kapp, Anne-France, Draganidis, Dimitrios, Pinaud, Stéphane, Vuichoud, Jacques, Shevlyakova, Maya, Rade-Kukic, Koraljka and Breuillé, Denis. (2019). Ingestion of a pre-bedtime protein containing beverage prevents overnight induced negative whole body protein balance in healthy middle-aged men : A randomized trial. Frontiers in Nutrition. 6, p. Article 181. https://doi.org/10.3389/fnut.2019.00181
Longitudinal association of dietary protein intake in infancy and adiposity throughout childhood
Jen, Vincent, Braun, Kim V. E., Karagounis, Leonidas G., Nguyen, Anh N., Jaddoe, Vincent W. V., Schoufour, Josje D., Franco, Oscar H. and Voortman, Trudy. (2019). Longitudinal association of dietary protein intake in infancy and adiposity throughout childhood. Clinical Nutrition. 38(3), pp. 1296-1302. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.clnu.2018.05.013
Intermittent fasting, energy balance and associated health outcomes in adults : Study protocol for a randomised controlled trial
Templeman, Iain, Thompson, Dylan, Gonzalez, Javier T., Walhin, Jean-Philippe, Reeves, Sue, Rogers, Phoebe, Brunstrom, Jeffrey M., Karagounis, Leonidas, Tsintzas, Kostas and Betts, James A.. (2018). Intermittent fasting, energy balance and associated health outcomes in adults : Study protocol for a randomised controlled trial. Trials. 19(1), pp. 1-11. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13063-018-2451-8
Post-game high protein intake may improve recovery of football-specific performance during a congested game fixture : Results from the PRO-FOOTBALL study
Poulios, Athanasios, Fatouros, Ioannis G., Mohr, Magni, Draganidis, Dimitrios, Deli, Chariklia K., Papanikolaou, Konstantinos, Sovatzidis, Apostolos, Nakopoulou, Theofano, Ermidis, Georgios, Tzatzakis, Theofanis, Laschou, Vasiliki C., Georgakouli, Kalliopi, Koulouris, Agisilaos, Tsimeas, Panagiotis, Chatzinikolaou, Athanasios, Karagounis, Leonidas G., Batsilas, Dimitrios, Krustrup, Peter and Jamurtas, Athanasios Z.. (2018). Post-game high protein intake may improve recovery of football-specific performance during a congested game fixture : Results from the PRO-FOOTBALL study. Nutrients. 10(4), p. Article 494. https://doi.org/10.3390/nu10040494
Dietary protein intake in school-age children and detailed measures of body composition : The Generation R Study
Jen, Vincent, Karagounis, Leonidas G., Jaddoe, Vincent W. V., Franco, Oscar H. and Voortman, Trudy. (2018). Dietary protein intake in school-age children and detailed measures of body composition : The Generation R Study. International Journal of Obesity. 42(10), pp. 1715-1723. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41366-018-0098-x
Disparate habitual physical activity and dietary intake profiles of elderly men with low and elevated systemic inflammation
Draganidis, Dimitrios, Jamurtas, A, Stampoulis, Theodoros, Laschou, Vasiliki C., Deli, Chariklia K., Georgakouli, Kalliopi, Papanikolaou, Konstantinos, Chatzinikolaou, A, Michalopoulou, Maria, Papadopoulos, Constantinos, Tsimeas, Panagiotis, Chondrogianni, Niki, Koutedakis, Yiannis, Karagounis, Leonidas and Fatouros, i. (2018). Disparate habitual physical activity and dietary intake profiles of elderly men with low and elevated systemic inflammation. Nutrients. 10(5), p. Article 566. https://doi.org/10.3390/nu10050566
Protein intake at breakfast promotes a positive whole-body protein balance in a dose-response manner in healthy children : A randomized trial
Karagounis, Leonidas G., Volterman, Kimberly A., Breuillé, Denis, Offord, Elizabeth A., Emady-Azar, Shahram and Moore, Daniel R.. (2018). Protein intake at breakfast promotes a positive whole-body protein balance in a dose-response manner in healthy children : A randomized trial. The Journal of Nutrition. 148(5), pp. 729-737. https://doi.org/10.1093/jn/nxy026
Timing and pattern of postexercise protein ingestion affects whole-body protein balance in healthy children : A randomized trial
Volterman, Kimberly A., Moore, Daniel R., Breithaupt, Peter, Grathwohl, Dominik, Offord, Elizabeth A., Karagounis, Leonidas G. and Timmons, Brian W.. (2017). Timing and pattern of postexercise protein ingestion affects whole-body protein balance in healthy children : A randomized trial. Applied Physiology, Nutrition and Metabolism. 42(11), pp. 1142-1148. https://doi.org/10.1139/apnm-2017-0185
Protein ingestion preserves proteasome activity during intense aseptic inflammation and facilitates skeletal muscle recovery in humans
Draganidis, Dimitrios, Chondrogianni, Niki, Chatzinikolaou, Athanasios, Terzis, Gerasimos, Karagounis, Leonidas G., Sovatzidis, Apostolos, Avloniti, Alexandra, Lefaki, Maria, Protopapa, Maria, Deli, Chariklia K., Papanikolaou, Konstantinos, Jamurtas, Athanasios Z. and Fatouros, Ioannis G.. (2017). Protein ingestion preserves proteasome activity during intense aseptic inflammation and facilitates skeletal muscle recovery in humans. British Journal of Nutrition. 118(3), pp. 189-200. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0007114517001829
Amino acid composition of breast milk from urban Chinese mothers
Garcia-Rodenas, Clara L., Affolter, Michael, Vinyes-Parès, Gerard, De Castro, Carlos A., Karagounis, Leonidas G., Zhang, Yumei, Wang, Peiyu and Thakkar, Sagar K.. (2016). Amino acid composition of breast milk from urban Chinese mothers. Nutrients. 8(10), p. Article 606. https://doi.org/10.3390/nu8100606
Inflammaging and skeletal muscle : Can protein intake make a difference?
Draganidis, Dimitrios, Karagounis, Leonidas G., Athanailidis, Ioannis, Chatzinikolaou, Athanasios, Jamurtas, Athanasios Z. and Fatouros, Ioannis G.. (2016). Inflammaging and skeletal muscle : Can protein intake make a difference? The Journal of Nutrition. 146(10), pp. 1940-1952. https://doi.org/10.3945/jn.116.230912